How should Christians apply Titus 3:10 in modern church conflicts? Text of Titus 3:10 “Reject a divisive man after a first and second admonition.” Historical and Literary Context Titus received apostolic authority from Paul to “set in order what was unfinished” on Crete (Titus 1:5). The letter concentrates on sound doctrine, qualified leadership, and the protection of fledgling congregations from false teachers who were already “upsetting whole households” (1:11). Verse 10 falls in the closing ethical section (3:1-11) where Paul contrasts gospel-shaped living with factious controversies. The warning is immediately followed by verse 11: “knowing that such a man is corrupt and sinful; he is self-condemned.” Thus, Paul seals the instruction with a characterization of the offender’s spiritual state, highlighting the pastoral urgency. Comparative Scriptural Framework • Matthew 18:15-17 – private reproof, escalating to public discipline and, if unrepentant, removal. • Romans 16:17 – mark and avoid those causing divisions contrary to the doctrine learned. • 1 Corinthians 5 – remove the persistent sinner “so that his spirit may be saved.” • 2 Thessalonians 3:6,14-15 – keep away yet treat him as a brother, not an enemy. • 2 Timothy 2:23-26 – correct opponents with gentleness, hoping God grants repentance. Together these passages form a cohesive disciplinary template: admonish, seek repentance, protect the flock, pursue restoration when possible. Theological Rationale 1. Purity of the Gospel – A church buys peace at too high a price if it tolerates a teacher who undermines creation, incarnation, or resurrection (cf. Galatians 1:6-9). 2. Unity of the Body – Jesus prayed that believers “may be one” (John 17:21). Divisiveness fractures Christ’s witness (John 13:35). 3. Protection of the Flock – Shepherds must guard against “savage wolves” (Acts 20:29-30). 4. Testimony to Outsiders – Discipline, rightly performed, displays God’s holiness and love (Hebrews 12:6-11). Identifying Modern “Divisive” Behavior • Persistently teaching doctrine the church has formally judged unbiblical. • Sowing suspicion toward qualified elders. • Rallying cliques around secondary issues (e.g., end-times charts, musical style) to the detriment of gospel mission. • Using social media to caricature leaders or poison fellowship. Pastoral Procedure for Application Today 1. Initial Investigation a. Verify facts (Deuteronomy 19:15; 1 Timothy 5:19). b. Distinguish essentials (e.g., deity of Christ) from non-essentials (e.g., carpet color). 2. First Admonition a. Private, respectful, Scripture-saturated conversation (Galatians 6:1). b. Clear call to repent and cease divisive action. c. Offer resources for study, counseling, or mentoring. 3. Second Admonition a. Include additional witnesses/elders (Matthew 18:16). b. Document the interaction; set a timeframe for response. c. Pray corporately for the individual’s restoration. 4. Rejection If Unrepentant a. Publicly communicate the decision to the congregation (1 Timothy 5:20). b. Remove from teaching, leadership, membership, or communion as appropriate. c. Maintain personal openness for future repentance (2 Corinthians 2:6-8). Historical Case Studies • Second-century churches read Paul’s letter publicly to expose the Gnostics’ factionalism; Irenaeus reports churches “united” against heresy (Against Heresies 3.4). • The Council of Nicaea (A.D. 325) followed the Pauline model, giving Arius opportunity to recant before ultimate expulsion. • The nineteenth-century Downgrade Controversy saw Charles Spurgeon withdraw from the Baptist Union when repeated admonitions over scriptural authority were ignored—an application of Titus 3:10 that preserved gospel clarity. Guardrails for Avoiding Misuse • Do not weaponize the verse to silence legitimate questions (Acts 17:11). • Ensure the accused clearly understands the doctrinal or behavioral charge. • Apply the same standard to influential donors or staff as to every member (James 2:1-4). • Pair firmness with pastoral grief, mirroring Paul’s tears over opponents (Philippians 3:18). Practical Checklist for Elders and Congregations □ Have we prayed and fasted for wisdom? □ Have we grounded every admonition in explicit Scripture? □ Are we unified as leaders before we confront? □ Have we offered pathways to repentance and education? □ Are we prepared to communicate the decision graciously to outsiders? □ Will we welcome the person back upon genuine repentance? Common Objections Answered “Isn’t exclusion unloving?” – Divine love includes discipline (Proverbs 3:12; Revelation 3:19). “Wasn’t Paul tolerant of differing views on food and days?” – Romans 14 concerns secondary matters; Titus 3 addresses divisive spirits threatening gospel integrity. “Won’t this create bad publicity?” – Obedience to God outweighs optics; moreover, transparent discipline often earns respect for integrity. Outcome When Biblical Discipline Is Practiced • The church’s witness is strengthened (Philippians 1:27). • False teaching loses its platform (2 Peter 2:1-3). • The repentant offender can be fully restored (2 Corinthians 2:7-8). • God is glorified through a holy, unified body (Ephesians 5:25-27). Conclusion Titus 3:10 calls modern believers to courageous, compassionate action. By following the apostolic sequence—two admonitions followed by rejection when necessary—churches safeguard doctrinal purity, foster genuine unity, and display the character of the resurrected Christ to a watching world. |
    |