How does Elkanah's polygamy in 1 Samuel 1:2 reflect cultural practices then? The Text 1 Samuel 1:2: “And he had two wives: one was named Hannah and the other Peninnah. Peninnah had children, but Hannah had none.” Cultural Setting of Marriage in the Era • Patrilineal society—family name and inheritance passed through sons (Genesis 15:2–3). • High infant mortality; multiple wives increased the likelihood of surviving heirs. • Social security was tied to descendants (Psalm 127:3–5). • Local Near-Eastern cultures practiced polygamy openly; Israel’s neighbors (e.g., Mesopotamia, Canaan) normalized it. • Mosaic Law regulated—not endorsed—polygamy (Exodus 21:10; Deuteronomy 21:15-17), limiting abuse and protecting inheritance rights. Why Elkanah Took Two Wives • Desire for offspring: Hannah’s barrenness (1 Samuel 1:5-6) likely prompted a second marriage so the family line would continue. • Cultural acceptability: Elkanah’s choice fit a customary solution already modeled by Abraham (Genesis 16) and Jacob (Genesis 29–30). • Economic capacity: Polygamy usually required resources; Elkanah’s yearly trips to Shiloh (1 Samuel 1:3) imply financial stability. How Elkanah’s Situation Reflects Broader Old-Testament Patterns • Patriarchal precedents: Abraham, Jacob, and later David and Solomon also had multiple wives (Genesis 25:6; 2 Samuel 5:13). • Ongoing tension: Rivalry and heartache frequently accompanied polygamy—Sarah/Hagar, Leah/Rachel, Peninnah/Hannah—highlighting its problems. • Covenantal storyline: These family conflicts propel redemptive history forward (Hannah’s barren-to-blessed arc leads to Samuel’s birth and Israel’s prophetic renewal). Scripture’s Evaluation of Polygamy • Original design: “For this reason a man shall leave his father and mother and be joined to his wife, and they shall become one flesh” (Genesis 2:24). • Tolerated, never ideal: Narrative portrayals emphasize sorrow and strife rather than fulfillment (cf. Deuteronomy 17:17 warning kings not to “multiply wives”). • Progressive clarification: Prophets and wisdom literature elevate the faithful, singular wife (Proverbs 5:18-19; Malachi 2:15). • New-Testament standard: Church leaders must be “the husband of one wife” (1 Timothy 3:2). Takeaways for Today • Scripture records cultural realities honestly while still upholding God’s unchanging marital blueprint. • Even practices God permits for a season reveal human need and point toward His better plan. • Elkanah’s household shows that solutions outside God’s ideal often produce pain—yet the Lord graciously works through imperfect circumstances to accomplish His purposes (Romans 8:28). |
    |