What historical evidence supports the events described in Matthew 23:35? Text of Matthew 23:35 “…so on you will come all the righteous blood shed on the earth, from the blood of righteous Abel to the blood of Zechariah son of Berechiah, whom you murdered between the temple and the altar.” Scope and Method The verse names two historical murders—Abel’s at the dawn of human history and Zechariah’s at the close of the Hebrew canon—and places the latter in a precise location inside the Second Temple. The following lines gather the primary and secondary evidence that these events truly happened, moving from the earliest to the latest witnesses and ending with manuscript testimony for Matthew’s own wording. Abel: Earliest Witnesses to the First Martyr 1.1 Genesis 4 (Masoretic, Septuagint, and 4QGenb) – Identical core narrative across all textual traditions, with 4QGenb (Dead Sea Scrolls, c. 150 BC) proving the story’s antiquity centuries before Christ. 1.2 Josephus, Antiquities 1.53–55 – Jewish historian (AD 90s) retells the murder as accepted history, not allegory. 1.3 Book of Jubilees 4.1–8 (2nd c. BC) – Details Cain’s jealousy, Abel’s sacrifice, and the curse; counted authoritative at Qumran (cf. 4Q216). 1.4 Rabbinic echoes – Mishnah Sanhedrin 4:5 cites Abel to ground capital-punishment ethics; Targum Onkelos renders the Hebrew in Aramaic for synagogue use. 1.5 Geological corroboration – Globally-stacked, rapidly-deposited sedimentary megasequences (e.g., Grand Canyon’s Coconino to Kaibab stack) fit a young-earth Flood model that places Abel only centuries, not eons, before the layers formed. 1.6 Population genetics – Mitochondrial-DNA “Eve” and Y-chromosome “Adam” bottlenecks are best explained by a recent common ancestry (<10,000 years) when calculated with empirically measured mutation rates (Sanford, Carter et al., 2018). Zechariah son of Berechiah: Identifying the Victim 2.1 2 Chronicles 24:20-22 – Records Zechariah son of Jehoiada stoned “in the court of the house of the LORD.” Chronicles is the last book in the traditional Hebrew order, making Zechariah the final recorded martyr of the canon. Jehoiada’s grandson could legitimately bear his more prominent ancestor’s name Berechiah (cf. Isaiah 37:2 = 2 Kings 19:2 for identical grandfather-naming). 2.2 Septuagint Chronicon – Greek text mirrors the Hebrew description, establishing a pre-Christian witness to the murder. 2.3 Targum Lamentations 2:20 – Paraphrases the murder of “Zechariah the son of Iddo [sc. Berechiah] the priest,” placing it in the Temple to explain the city’s fall. 2.4 Babylonian Talmud, Gittin 57b – Speaks of the Temple stone floor still “boiling” with Zechariah’s blood until Nebuzaradan slew priests to avenge him, an independent Jewish memory of the crime. 2.5 Josephus, Antiquities 9.168-171 – Describes King Joash ordering Zechariah’s execution in the Temple court, harmonizing with Chronicles. 2.6 Epigraphic data – Seventh-century-BC bullae from Jerusalem bearing names with the root ברכיהו (Berechiah) confirm the name’s popularity in the precise period of Chronicles’ Zechariah. “Between the Temple and the Altar”: Archaeological Plausibility 3.1 Temple layout – The Mishnah (Middot 3:1) locates the great altar 22 cubits from the entrance to the vestibule, leaving a paved court large enough for stoning. 3.2 Excavations on the Temple Mount’s southwest corner (Herodian paving stones, ash layers, and priestly inscription fragments) prove that a court-area matching Mishnah dimensions existed in the first century and earlier. Nothing in the known architecture contradicts Matthew’s spatial detail. Canon-Bracketing as Internal Evidence 4.1 From Genesis to Chronicles – By citing Abel (Genesis) and Zechariah (Chronicles), Jesus sweeps through the entire recognized Scripture of His day, an apologetic shorthand accepted by His hearers. The ease with which He does so indicates a closed canonical list prior to AD 30, undercutting theories of late canonical fluidity. Fulfilled Prediction: First-Century Confirmation 5.1 Matthew 23:36 – “Truly I tell you, all these things will come upon this generation.” 5.2 Josephus, War 6.3-6 – Chronicles the massacre of priests and people on the Temple grounds in AD 70, within one generation, exactly matching Christ’s forecast and vindicating His prophetic authority. New Testament Manuscript Evidence for Matthew 23:35 6.1 Papyrus 64+67 (Magdalen, c. AD 175) – Contains vv. 31-39 with no substantive variants. 6.2 Papyrus 45 (c. AD 200), Codices Vaticanus (B), Sinaiticus (ℵ), Ephraemi (C), Bezae (D) – All preserve the verse intact; no extant Greek witness omits Zechariah’s patronym. 6.3 Early Patristic citations – Origen, Commentary on Matthew 13.33 (c. AD 245) and Eusebius, Demonstratio 3.2 quote the verse verbatim, proving transmission stability. Theological and Philosophical Implications 7.1 Moral continuity – The shed blood of Abel inaugurates, and Zechariah’s concludes, the record of persecution; Jesus assumes both as real, thus validating Genesis’ early-earth chronology and Chronicles’ late-monarchic history in one breath. 7.2 Judicial certainty – The unavenged blood calls for divine judgment, an ethical argument that only holds if the murders are factual, not metaphorical. 7.3 Christ’s self-attestation – Accurate recall of otherwise obscure events (especially Zechariah’s patronym) evidences omniscience and underlines the reliability of His resurrection-attested claim to deity. Summary of Historical Support • Multiple independent Jewish sources (Chronicles, Targums, Talmud, Josephus) affirm Zechariah’s death in the Temple. • Dead Sea Scrolls, Josephus, and Second-Temple literature treat Abel as an historical individual. • Archaeology corroborates the physical setting described. • All known Greek manuscripts of Matthew secure the wording. • The subsequent fulfillment of Christ’s attached prophecy (AD 70) supplies real-time validation. Taken together, these lines of evidence form a coherent historical chain demonstrating that Matthew 23:35 recounts concrete events, not legend, and they reinforce the unified trustworthiness of the entire biblical record from Genesis to the Gospels. |
    |