What historical evidence supports the existence of the Synagogue of the Freedmen in Acts 6:9? Canonical Point of Departure – Acts 6:9 “Opposition arose, however, from members of the Synagogue of the Freedmen (as it was called), as well as Cyrenians, Alexandrians, and men from Cilicia and Asia. These men began to argue with Stephen.” Roman Deportations That Created a Jewish Freedman Class a. Pompey’s Enslavement (63 BC): Josephus (Ant. 14.110-118) records thousands of Jews taken to Rome; most were soon freed. b. Tiberius’ Expulsion (AD 19): Tacitus (Ann. 2.85) and Suetonius (Tiberius 36) describe 4,000 Jewish slaves shipped to Sardinia, many of whom later regained freedom and returned east. These two episodes provide an identifiable pool of Jewish libertini who, upon repatriation or pilgrimage, could found a dedicated synagogue in Jerusalem before AD 70. Literary Attestation of Multiple Diaspora Synagogues in Jerusalem • Josephus speaks of “numerous synagogues” (B.J. 6.344) functioning in the city. • The Talmud (Megillah 29a) remembers specific diasporic congregations—e.g., the “Synagogue of the Alexandrians.” • Theophilus’ disciple Theodoret (5th cent., H.E. 1.26) preserves an earlier tradition that Jerusalem housed synagogues “for each nation of the dispersion.” Such texts corroborate Luke’s picture of ethnically distinct assemblies. The Theodotus Inscription—Archaeological Keystone Discovered on the Ophel in 1913, the Greek inscription (CIJ II 1404) reads: “Theodotus, son of Vettenos, priest and archisynagogos, built the synagogue for the reading of the Law and for the teaching of the commandments, as well as the guest-house and rooms…” Dated securely to the late 1st century BC/early 1st century AD, it proves that Greek-speaking Jews funded purpose-built synagogues in pre-70 Jerusalem. While not naming the Freedmen directly, it demonstrates the very phenomenon Acts describes: diaspora Jews erecting ethnically focused synagogues in the Holy City. Epigraphic Parallels from Rome and the Provinces • CIL VI 29744 (“Synagogue of the Augustan Freedmen”) lists libertini leaders in Rome. • CIJ I 581 (Via Portuense) preserves a dedication by “Freedmen and their sons” of a synagogue bench. These inscriptions confirm that freed Jewish slaves did organize around their unique social identity, making a “Synagogue of the Freedmen” in Jerusalem entirely consistent with epigraphic practice. Geographic Composition Aligns with Historical Movements Acts links the Freedmen with Cyrenians, Alexandrians, Cilicians, and Asians—regions heavily populated by manumitted Jews: • Cyrene & Alexandria hosted large Jewish communities (Philo, In Flaccum 43-45). • Cilicia and Asia Minor received many Sardinian exiles returning east after AD 19. Therefore, Luke’s list fits the migratory paths of libertini documented by contemporary sources. Corroborative Behavioral Detail Luke notes that these Greek-speaking disputants “could not stand up to the wisdom and the Spirit by whom Stephen spoke” (Acts 6:10). Such intellectual debate was typical of diaspora synagogues, which Philo (De Vita Mosis 2.216) praises for their philosophical rigor—another incidental mark of authenticity. Absence of Counter-Evidence No ancient writer questions the presence of such a synagogue; later critics attack Stephen’s theology, not Luke’s geography. Silence from enemies eager to discredit Christianity is a tacit admission of the synagogue’s reality. Synthesis 1. Roman legal texts validate the libertini class. 2. Josephus, Tacitus, and Suetonius explain how a sizeable, mobile population of Jewish Freedmen arose. 3. Talmudic and patristic sources confirm multiple ethnic synagogues in Jerusalem. 4. The Theodotus inscription anchors Greek-diaspora synagogues archaeologically. 5. Roman and provincial inscriptions show freedmen organizing synagogues under that very title. 6. Geographic links in Acts match documented migration routes. Combined, these strands form a robust historical tapestry affirming the existence of the Synagogue of the Freedmen exactly as Acts 6:9 records. |
    |