How to identify true vs. false prophets?
What criteria can we use to discern true prophets from false ones?

Setting the Scene

The year Isaiah 594 BC. Hananiah has just delivered a feel-good prophecy promising swift freedom from Babylon. Jeremiah, holding the wooden yoke God told him to wear, answers with heaven’s verdict: Hananiah is lying.


Key Verse: Jeremiah 28:15

“Then the prophet Jeremiah said to Hananiah the prophet, ‘Listen, Hananiah! The LORD has not sent you, yet you have persuaded this people to trust in a lie.’”


Why Discernment Matters

• A single false voice can “persuade” an entire nation (Jeremiah 28:15).

• Trusting the lie always leads to ruin (Jeremiah 28:16-17).

• God never leaves His people without clear standards to expose deception (Isaiah 8:20).


Four Core Tests of a Prophet

1. The Sending Test: Has the LORD truly commissioned this person?

– Jeremiah flatly states, “The LORD has not sent you” (Jeremiah 28:15).

– God alone chooses and calls His messengers (Amos 7:14-15).

– Self-appointment is the first red flag.

2. The Fidelity Test: Does the message agree with previously revealed Scripture?

Deuteronomy 13:1-3: even if signs accompany the message, any departure from covenant truth marks it false.

Isaiah 8:20: “To the law and to the testimony! If they do not speak according to this word, there is no light in them.”

Galatians 1:8: no “new” gospel is allowed.

3. The Fulfillment Test: Do the predictions come to pass?

Deuteronomy 18:22: accuracy must be 100 percent.

Jeremiah 28:16-17: Hananiah dies exactly as Jeremiah foretold, proving God was with Jeremiah, not Hananiah.

Ezekiel 33:33: “Then they will know a prophet has been among them” when the word comes true.

4. The Fruit Test: What results follow the message and the messenger?

Matthew 7:15-20: good trees bear good fruit; false prophets are recognized by rotten fruit.

Jeremiah 23:14: false prophets strengthen evildoers and spread ungodliness.

1 John 4:1-3: true prophecy exalts the real Jesus and fosters love-sourced obedience.


Additional Markers

• Humility vs. showmanship (Jeremiah 28:11 vs. Jeremiah 26:12).

• Willingness to suffer for the word (Jeremiah 20:2; Hebrews 11:36-38).

• Consistency over time (2 Chron 18:13; Proverbs 12:19).


Putting It into Practice

• Measure every modern voice by Scripture first, not charisma.

• Track long-term fruit and fulfilled (or failed) predictions.

• Remember: God’s true word may wound before it heals, but it never flatters people into trusting a lie.

How does Jeremiah 28:15 warn against false prophecy in today's church teachings?
Top of Page
Top of Page