How does Jeremiah 23:23 address false prophets? Canonical Text “Am I only a God nearby,” declares the LORD, “and not a God far away?” (Jeremiah 23:23) Immediate Context: Jeremiah 23:9-32 The entire oracle condemns prophets who fabricate visions, plagiarize each other’s words, and turn Yahweh’s people from covenant fidelity. Verses 21-22, 25-27, and 30-32 explicitly expose their deceit. Verse 23 interrupts the denunciation with a rhetorical question that reveals the theological error beneath their practice: they act as though God’s knowledge is limited to whatever they display publicly before the people. Yahweh declares His omnipresence and omniscience, nullifying every pretense of secrecy. Historical Setting Around 597–586 BC Judah staggered under Babylonian threat. Competing prophetic voices offered reassuring dreams of peace (v. 17) in direct conflict with Jeremiah’s message of impending judgment. Social pressure to silence Jeremiah (cf. Jeremiah 20:2; 26:11) incentivized counterfeit prophecy. Verse 23 reminds both prophets and hearers that God’s presence is not confined to temple precincts or public assemblies; He observes every private conversation, dream circle, and scribal workshop. Literary Function of v. 23 1. Pivot: It turns the focus from the false prophets’ external activity to God’s internal scrutiny. 2. Irony: They claim insider “revelation,” yet the all-seeing God unveils their deception. 3. Inclusio with v. 24: Verse 24 (“Do I not fill the heavens and the earth?”) completes the thought, forming an emphatic couplet that brackets the accusation. Theology: Omnipresence and Omniscience Against Deceit Yahweh’s question affirms two attributes: • Immanence (“nearby”): He is present in Judah’s immediate affairs. • Transcendence (“far away”): He simultaneously rules the cosmos. False prophets implicitly deny at least one of these. If they think God is only “near,” they imagine His perspective is provincial and can be manipulated. If they treat Him as only “far,” they view Him as detached and unconcerned with their lies. Verse 23 collapses that dichotomy—He is both. Polemic Against the Mechanics of False Prophecy • Secret Dream-Sessions: vv. 25-27 expose a practice of trading dream language. God’s omnipresence renders the secrecy futile. • Borrowed Oracles: v. 30 denounces plagiarism. An omniscient God knows the origin of every word. • Mass Approval: v. 16 shows people flocking to soothing messages. God’s scope (“far away”) reaches beyond crowd consensus. Intertextual Support • Deuteronomy 18:20-22—death prescribed for the prophet who speaks presumptuously; the test assumes an omniscient Judge. • Psalm 139:7-12—David celebrates the same omnipresence invoked in Jeremiah 23:23. • Ezekiel 13:1-9—parallel denunciation of “whitewashed” visions. • Hebrews 4:13—“Nothing in all creation is hidden from God’s sight.” Archaeological Corroboration of Jeremiah’s Setting Bullae reading “Belonging to Jehucal son of Shelemiah” (excavated in 2005 in the City of David) match Jeremiah 37:3; 38:1, anchoring Jeremiah’s ministry in verifiable history and lending indirect credence to the accuracy of the surrounding oracles, including 23:23. Application for Discernment Today 1. Test all spiritual claims against canonical Scripture (1 John 4:1). 2. Evaluate fruit and motive; God discerns what listeners cannot (Matthew 7:15-20). 3. Remember divine omnipresence in private ministry contexts; no platform, pulpit, or podcast is beyond scrutiny. Christological Fulfillment Jesus embodies Jeremiah’s principle: “He needed no testimony about man, for He knew what was in a man” (John 2:25). His resurrection (1 Corinthians 15:3-8) vindicates divine omniscience and ensures final judgment on every false word (Matthew 12:36). Eschatological Warning False prophecy escalates in the last days (Matthew 24:24). Jeremiah 23:23 prepares believers to reject end-time deception by anchoring confidence in an omnipresent, omniscient Lord. Pastoral Consolation For the faithful remnant Jeremiah addressed—and for believers today—God’s nearness guarantees companionship amid persecution, and His transcendence guarantees sovereignty over global threats. Summary Jeremiah 23:23 confronts false prophets by asserting God’s simultaneous immanence and transcendence. The verse demolishes any illusion that deceptive speech escapes divine notice, grounds the ethical demand for prophetic integrity, and equips God’s people to discern truth in every generation. |
    |