Lessons on obedience from Saul?
What can we learn from Saul's actions about obedience to God?

The Setting: Saul at Amalek

1 Samuel 15:5 sets the scene: “Saul came to the city of Amalek and lay in wait in the valley.”

Background from verses 1–4 gives God’s clear, literal command: “Now go, attack the Amalekites and devote to destruction all that belongs to them…” (v. 3). Scripture presents this command as historically true and morally authoritative.


What Saul Actually Did

• Gathered the army and advanced on Amalek

• Defeated the Amalekites (vv. 7–8)

• Captured Agag alive and kept “the best of the sheep, cattle, fatlings, lambs, and all that was good” (v. 9)


Surface Obedience vs. Full Obedience

• Saul obeyed geographically—he went where God sent him

• He obeyed militarily—he fought the battle God ordered

• He disobeyed spiritually—he re-wrote the terms of total destruction


Where Partial Obedience Leads

• Self-justification (v. 13) “I have carried out the LORD’s command.”

• Selective listening (v. 15) “The people spared the best… to sacrifice to the LORD your God.”

• Divine grief (vv. 10–11) “I regret that I have made Saul king, because he has turned away from Me.”


God’s Assessment of Obedience

1 Samuel 15:22 “Behold, obedience is better than sacrifice, and attentiveness than the fat of rams.”

• God values complete adherence over impressive offerings

• Delayed or edited obedience counts as disobedience

• True obedience flows from reverence, not convenience


Consequences of Saul’s Choices

• Loss of divine favor (v. 26) “You have rejected the word of the LORD, and the LORD has rejected you as king.”

• Kingdom torn away (v. 28)

• Ongoing trouble for Israel (31:1–6 shows Saul’s tragic end)


Timeless Principles on Obedience

• God’s commands are literal, clear, and non-negotiable

• Obedience must be total—holding back “just the best parts” is still rebellion

• The appearance of religious devotion cannot compensate for disobedience

• Leadership carries heavier accountability (Luke 12:48)


Echoes in the Rest of Scripture

Deuteronomy 28—blessing linked to wholehearted obedience

Joshua 11:15—Joshua “left nothing undone” of all the LORD commanded

John 14:15—“If you love Me, you will keep My commandments.”

James 1:22—“Be doers of the word, and not hearers only, deceiving yourselves.”


Living Out These Lessons Today

• Read God’s Word expecting literal guidance, not suggestions

• Resist editing commands to fit personal preference or cultural pressure

• Measure obedience by God’s standard, not by comparison with others

• Act promptly and completely when Scripture speaks—partial compliance invites spiritual drift

Saul reached the right place but stopped short of full obedience. His story stands as a caution and a call: when God speaks, His people respond without subtraction, delay, or negotiation.

How does 1 Samuel 15:5 demonstrate Saul's approach to God's commands?
Top of Page
Top of Page