What does Luke 5:34 reveal about Jesus' view on fasting and its purpose? Text of Luke 5:34 “Jesus replied, ‘Can you make the guests of the bridegroom fast while he is with them?’ ” Immediate Narrative Context (Luke 5:33-35) Pharisees and scribes observe that John’s disciples and their own practice regular fasts, whereas Jesus’ disciples are feasting. Jesus answers with the bridegroom image in v. 34 and adds in v. 35, “But the time will come when the bridegroom will be taken from them; then they will fast.” The pericope is framed by two additional metaphors (new cloth on old garment, new wine in old skins, vv. 36-39), underscoring covenantal newness. Second-Temple Background of Fasting • Torah requires a single national fast on the Day of Atonement (Leviticus 16:29-31). • Post-exilic Judaism multiplied fasts (Zechariah 8:19). By the first century, the Pharisaic norm was twice-weekly (Luke 18:12; m. Taʿan 1:4-7). • Fasting symbolized national mourning, repentance, intercession, and expectation for messianic deliverance (Joel 2:12-17; Daniel 9:3). The questioners assume such ascetic rigor marks authentic piety. The Bridegroom Metaphor: Christological Claim A. Old Testament Bridegroom = Yahweh: Isaiah 62:5; Hosea 2:19-20. B. John the Baptist already calls Jesus “the bridegroom” (John 3:29). C. By adopting the title, Jesus implicitly identifies Himself with Yahweh, asserting divine status. Theological Logic of Jesus’ Answer A wedding feast and a funeral are mutually exclusive emotions; joy is inappropriate in mourning and vice versa. Jesus locates His incarnate presence in the category of eschatological wedding joy. Therefore: • Mandatory fasting during His earthly ministry would deny the reality of Immanuel. • Ritual acts are subordinate to Christ’s redemptive timetable. Purpose of Fasting Reframed 1. Relational, not meritorious – a hunger for God’s presence (Psalm 63:1). 2. Appropriate to absence and longing – “when the bridegroom will be taken” (crucifixion, ascension). 3. Sign of repentance and dependence, never self-display (Matthew 6:16-18). Canonical Intertexture • OT wedding-banquet prophecies (Isaiah 25:6-9) meet NT fulfillment (Revelation 19:7-9). • Jesus’ “taken” echoes Isaiah 53:8; His death introduces the Church Age in which believers await His return (Acts 1:9-11), the proper context for voluntary fasting (Acts 13:2-3; 14:23). Practical Implications for the Church • Post-Pentecost believers fast to intensify prayer, seek guidance, and mourn sin, but always in Resurrection joy. • Early church fasted Wednesdays and Fridays (Didache 8.1), illustrating a balance of discipline and celebration (Acts 2:46). • Modern application: corporate days of prayer and fasting for evangelism, revival, and relief of persecution. Summary Statement Luke 5:34 reveals that fasting, while a valued spiritual practice, is purposive and seasonal. Its legitimacy pivots on the presence or perceived absence of the Bridegroom. During Jesus’ earthly ministry, joy in His company superseded ritual deprivation. After His ascension, fasting serves as a disciplined expression of longing for His return, repentance from sin, and dependence on divine grace—always subordinate to, and interpreted through, the completed work of the resurrected Christ. |
    |