What does Jesus mean by "If I want him to remain until I return" in John 21:22?

Immediate Context (John 21:18-23)

Jesus’ post-resurrection conversation on the shore of the Sea of Galilee concludes with a prophetic word to Peter and the corrective statement about John:

“Jesus answered, ‘If I want him to remain until I return, what is that to you? You follow Me!’ ” (John 21:22).

Verse 23 immediately clarifies, “Because of this, the rumor spread among the brothers that this disciple would not die. Yet Jesus did not say that he would not die, but only, ‘If I want him to remain until I return, what is that to you?’ ”

---

Literary Setting

John 21 forms an epilogue that balances the prologue (1:1-18). It re-commissions Peter (vv. 15-17), foretells his martyrdom (vv. 18-19), and settles potential rivalry by emphasizing individual obedience (vv. 20-22).

---

Grammatical Analysis

Greek text (Nestle-Aland 28): ἐὰν αὐτὸν θέλω μένειν ἕως ἔρχομαι, τί πρὸς σέ;

• ἐὰν … θέλω (“if I will/desire”) introduces a third-class conditional—possible but not certain.

• μένειν (“to remain,” present infinitive) carries Johannine connotations of abiding (cf. 15:4-7).

• ἔρχομαι (“I am coming”) uses the present tense for a future event, a stylistic device signaling imminence without calendrical precision (cf. 14:3; Revelation 22:7, 12, 20).

---

Early Church Testimony to John’s Longevity

• Irenaeus, Adv. Haer. 2.22.5, cites elders who knew John and place him alive “until the times of Trajan” (AD 98+).

• Eusebius, Hist. Ecclesiastes 3.23, records that John “survived all the apostles and lived into extreme old age.”

These reports dovetail with Jesus’ hypothetical clause: John did outlive the others, though not eternally.

---

Interpretive Options

1. Physical Survival until the Final Parousia

Church rumor (v. 23) embraced this, yet John’s eventual death proves the phrase hypothetical. The point is conditional sovereignty, not a calendar promise.

2. Survival until Christ’s “Coming” in Judgment on Jerusalem (AD 70)

John, likely in Ephesus, lived past the temple’s fall, satisfying the condition without requiring unending life. Jesus elsewhere calls that event a “coming” (Matthew 24:27-34).

3. Survival until the Revelatory “Coming” of the Apocalypse

John received and recorded the vision of Christ’s glory on Patmos (Revelation 1:9-19). In that sense, Christ “came” to John in visionary disclosure before John’s death.

4. Representative Continuance through Inspired Writings

“Remain” (μένειν) frequently refers to theological abiding. John’s Gospel, Epistles, and Revelation continuously testify until the Second Advent, so his witness “remains.”

All four views cohere with the conditional clause and do not conflict with inerrancy; the Spirit may intend layered fulfillment, a regular Johannine feature (e.g., double meanings in 2:19-22; 7:37-39).

---

Theological Emphasis—Individual Discipleship

Jesus redirects Peter from comparison to vocation: “You follow Me.” The issue is lordship, not lifespan equity. Biblical calling is personalized (Jeremiah 1:5; Ephesians 2:10). Obedience, not curiosity, is the disciple’s priority.

---

Pastoral and Behavioral Implications

Comparative spirituality breeds envy and distraction. Modern believers echo Peter when they ask why one Christian seems to prosper or suffer differently. John 21:22 counters with Christ’s sovereign prerogative and the imperative of personal faithfulness. Behavioral research confirms the corrosive effect of social comparison on well-being; Scripture anticipates this by focusing the believer’s gaze on Christ (Hebrews 12:1-2).

---

Eschatological Perspective

The clause sustains a tension between imminence and delay, a hallmark of New Testament eschatology (Philippians 4:5; 2 Peter 3:8-9). Christ’s sovereign timing supersedes human prognostication.

---

Summary

“If I want him to remain until I return” asserts Jesus’ authority over each disciple’s lifespan and mission. It is a conditional, not categorical, statement. Historically, John did remain the longest, possibly until the fall of Jerusalem and certainly until he received Revelation, thus partially fulfilling the saying while preserving its hypothetical force. The core lesson: focus on following Christ personally, trusting His sovereign plan for others.