What emotions did Reuben feel saying this?
What emotions might Reuben have felt when he said, "The boy is gone"?

Setting the Scene

“Reuben returned to the pit and saw that Joseph was not there; and he tore his clothes. He went back to his brothers and said, ‘The boy is gone! And I—where shall I go?’” (Genesis 37:29-30)


Immediate Shock and Panic

• Finding the pit empty jolted Reuben; the tearing of his clothes signals instant, visceral distress (Genesis 37:29).

• His cry, “The boy is gone!” is the outburst of someone blindsided, unable at first to process the new reality.


Overwhelming Grief and Sorrow

• In ancient Israel, rending garments was a public display of deep mourning (cf. Job 1:20).

• Joseph was his younger brother, flesh and blood; the thought that harm had come pierced Reuben’s heart with genuine grief.


Crushing Guilt and Self-Reproach

• Reuben had persuaded the others not to kill Joseph, planning to rescue him later (Genesis 37:21-22).

• His plan failed; the weight of personal responsibility now settled on him—“I—where shall I go?”

• Years later he still carried that guilt: “Did I not tell you, ‘Do not sin against the boy’?” (Genesis 42:22).


Fear of Facing His Father

• Jacob had already suffered loss; Reuben dreaded being the bearer of more devastating news.

• The thought of his father’s shattered heart intensified Reuben’s anxiety and dread (Genesis 37:35).


Sense of Powerlessness and Failure

• As firstborn, Reuben bore special duty (Genesis 49:3).

• The empty pit screamed that he had failed in his protective role, leaving him feeling helpless and defeated.


Shame and Remorse over Past Sins

• Reuben’s earlier moral lapse with Bilhah (Genesis 35:22) already marred his standing; this fresh failure likely magnified his shame.

• He may have felt that his own sin had compromised his authority, allowing catastrophe to unfold.


Anger and Frustration toward His Brothers

• Learning they had sold Joseph (Genesis 37:28) would kindle indignation—yet he was also complicit by absence.

• The mix of anger at them and anger at himself created inner turmoil.


Desperation for Redemption

• “Where shall I go?” reveals a man searching for a way to set things right, longing for restoration.

• His later offer to sacrifice his own sons for Benjamin’s safety (Genesis 42:37) shows an ongoing drive to make amends.


Takeaway for Today

Reuben’s cry exposes a heart churning with shock, sorrow, guilt, fear, shame, anger, and a desperate yearning for redemption. In his turmoil we see humanity’s need for forgiveness and restoration—a need fully met in the One greater than Reuben, our Lord Jesus Christ (Hebrews 2:17).

How does Genesis 37:30 reveal consequences of deceit among Joseph's brothers?
Top of Page
Top of Page