Why does Paul say sin is dead without the law in Romans 7:8? Text “But sin, seizing an opportunity through the commandment, produced in me every kind of covetous desire. For apart from the law, sin is dead.” — Romans 7:8 Immediate Context (Romans 7:1-13) Paul is addressing Jewish believers who “know the law” (7:1). He has just illustrated freedom from the Mosaic covenant by the death of a spouse (7:2-3) and has affirmed that believers “were made to die to the law through the body of Christ” (7:4). Verses 5-6 contrast our former state “in the flesh” with our present service “in the new way of the Spirit.” Verse 7 raises the objection, “Is the law sin?”—which Paul rejects. Verse 8 begins the explanation: the law is not sinful; rather, sin uses the law as a base of operations. Why Call Sin “Dead” Apart from Law? 1. Latent, Not Absent Paul does not claim people are morally perfect before encountering God’s statutes. He means sin lacks vitality—it lies dormant, unexposed, unprovoked, undefined (cf. Romans 5:13: “sin is not imputed when there is no law”). Think of radium sealed in lead: lethal yet inert until the shielding is removed. 2. Legal Non-Imputation Divine justice does not reckon transgression where no explicit command is given (Romans 4:15). Theologically, sin’s guilt is “dead” in the courtroom sense until a statute is violated, just as there is no citation for speeding where no speed limit exists. 3. Experiential Unawareness Before the command “You shall not covet,” Paul “was alive” (7:9)—living in a self-approved state. The law’s arrival awakened self-knowledge, not new desires. Augustine’s pear-theft illustrates: the thrill arose because it was forbidden (Confessions 2.4). 4. Contrast With Adam Adam’s prototype command (“you shall not eat,” Genesis 2:17) parallels the Sinai code. Adam’s sin “came into the world through one man” (Romans 5:12), yet until the Mosaic era sin was not defined with the same clarity; “death reigned… even over those whose sin was not like the transgression of Adam” (5:14). The law resuscitated Adam-like, consciously defiant sin in every Israelite. 5. Forensic Preparation for the Gospel Galatians 3:24: “The law became our tutor to lead us to Christ.” By invigorating sin, the law drives sinners to seek righteousness outside themselves—fulfilled in Christ’s substitutionary death and resurrection (1 Corinthians 15:3-4). Early Church Echoes • Chrysostom: “The prohibition made the transgression more apparent; it did not create the evil.” • Augustine: “The law is good in that it uncovers my disease; yet the disease, taking occasion, grows furious” (On Romans 7). Law’s Three Functions Clarified 1. Moral mirror—exposes sin (Romans 3:20). 2. Civil restraint—curbs external evil (1 Timothy 1:9-10). 3. Didactic guide for the redeemed (Psalm 19:7-11; Matthew 5:17-19). Romans 7 focuses on the first. Objection: “People Still Sin Without Sinai” True; conscience (Romans 2:14-15) renders all accountable. Yet conscience is an internal, dim witness. The written code externalizes, specifies, and intensifies violation, making sin “utterly sinful” (7:13). Practical Implications for Believers Believers are “released from the law” (7:6) in its condemning capacity. Nevertheless, the moral content reflects God’s character; walking in the Spirit, not legalism, fulfills it (Galatians 5:16-23). When temptation arises through prohibition, the remedy is union with the risen Christ whose Spirit empowers obedience (Romans 8:2-4). Conclusion Paul’s phrase “sin is dead without the law” conveys that sin’s power to accuse, arouse, and condemn is inert until the divine command confronts human fallenness. The law thereby proves humanity’s need for the Savior, driving us to the crucified and resurrected Christ, who alone frees from both sin’s penalty and dominion. |
    |