How many times did Jesus move away to pray in the gospels where he prayed to avoid the cross? Three (Matthew 26, Mark 14) or one (Luke 22)? Overview of the Gethsemane Narratives The Gospel accounts of Jesus’ prayer in Gethsemane are recorded in three places: Matthew 26:36–46, Mark 14:32–42, and Luke 22:39–46. Each evangelist highlights particular details. In both Matthew and Mark, Jesus separates from His disciples to pray on three distinct occasions. In Luke’s account, only one instance is mentioned, and the text does not repeat a second or third departure. Below is a thorough look at these passages with references from the Berean Standard Bible and a discussion of how they fit together. Matthew 26:36–46 (Three Separate Occasions) Matthew 26:36–46 recounts that after arriving at Gethsemane, Jesus tells His disciples: • “Sit here while I go over there and pray.” (Matthew 26:36) He then goes farther and prays. Notably, He returns to His disciples multiple times: 1. First departure: “He fell face down and prayed, ‘My Father, if it is possible, let this cup pass from Me. Yet not as I will, but as You will.’” (Matthew 26:39) – After this prayer, He returns and finds the disciples sleeping. 2. Second departure: “He went away a second time and prayed...” (Matthew 26:42) – Jesus again returns to the disciples. 3. Third departure: “He left them and went away once more and prayed a third time, saying the same thing.” (Matthew 26:44) Matthew is explicit that Jesus physically withdraws to pray three distinct times, returning to check on His disciples between each prayer. Mark 14:32–42 (Three Separate Occasions) Mark’s Gospel similarly narrates multiple prayers: • Upon arriving at Gethsemane, Jesus instructs His disciples: “Sit here while I pray.” (Mark 14:32) He also brings Peter, James, and John farther with Him and then separates Himself to pray. The parallel structure to Matthew shows: 1. First departure: “He fell to the ground and prayed that, if it were possible, the hour would pass from Him.” (Mark 14:35) – He returns to find the disciples sleeping. 2. Second departure: Mark indicates He “went away and prayed the same thing.” (Mark 14:39) – He returns again. 3. Third departure: Although Mark’s text does not detail the words of this third prayer separately, he indicates that Jesus again discovers them sleeping and finally says, “Enough! The hour has come.” (Mark 14:41) Like Matthew, Mark underscores that there are three distinct intervals in which Jesus leaves the group of disciples, prays, and comes back. Luke 22:39–46 (One Mentioned Session) Luke’s account focuses less on the repeated going and returning and more on the depth of Jesus’ agony. Luke 22:39–46 reads: • “He withdrew about a stone’s throw beyond them, where He knelt down and prayed...” (Luke 22:41) Within this passage, Luke does not describe multiple intervals. After this prayer, He reminds the disciples to pray, saying, “Get up and pray so that you will not enter into temptation.” (Luke 22:46) Luke’s emphasis is on the intensity of Christ’s anguish (where we learn that His sweat “became like drops of blood falling to the ground,” Luke 22:44), rather than enumerating each time that Jesus stepped away. Reconciling the Different Presentations • Focus and Emphasis: Each Gospel writer tailors the narrative to highlight key theological or pastoral themes. Matthew and Mark offer a structured depiction of three separate prayers, illustrating Christ’s persistent wrestling before His impending crucifixion. Luke compresses the event, emphasizing Jesus’ overwhelming distress and the disciples’ need to watch and pray. • Harmonization: Far from being contradictory, these details showcase different facets of the same episode. It is common in ancient biography to condense multiple events for brevity or thematic coherence. Luke does not deny multiple prayers; he simply focuses on one. • Textual Consistency: Early manuscript evidence, as consistently presented by scholars, confirms that the Gospels accurately preserve Jesus’ actions in Gethsemane. The variations in detail represent the complementing nature of independent eyewitness or source-based testimony. Theological Significance • Intensity of Christ’s Suffering: Whether mentioned once or three times, the prayers reveal Jesus’ full humanity in His genuine anguished plea. “Not My will, but Yours be done” (cf. Luke 22:42) underscores His submission to the Father’s will. • Demonstration of Persistence in Prayer: In Matthew and Mark, the repeating pattern underscores steadfast, persevering prayer in moments of crisis. • Encouragement to Believers: All three accounts end with Jesus and the disciples rising to face what is coming. The example of Christ’s dependence on the Father, even while fully knowing the Father’s plan, illustrates unwavering trust. Historical and Textual Support • Manuscript Evidence: Ancient manuscripts such as Codex Vaticanus and Codex Sinaiticus consistently preserve these passages, reinforcing the credibility of the accounts. • Archaeological Context: Gethsemane, an actual garden located on the Mount of Olives near Jerusalem, is well attested by early Christian writers and later archaeological findings. Its setting fits precisely with the descriptions in the Gospels. • Witness of the Early Church: Early believers widely regarded these Gethsemane narratives as authentic, using them in liturgical readings and catechetical instructions. Conclusion Matthew and Mark record Jesus separating from His disciples to pray on three occasions (Matthew 26:36–46; Mark 14:32–42). Luke, focusing on the intensity of Christ’s distress, mentions only one of those departures in detail (Luke 22:39–46), without giving a second or third session. Each Gospel thus contributes a distinct facet of the same event, and together they present a unified picture of Christ’s profound submission to the Father’s will. |
    |