Should Christians obey the government? (Romans 13:1-2 vs. Acts 5:29) I. Introduction to the Tension in Scripture Romans 13:1–2 declares, “Everyone must submit himself to the governing authorities, for there is no authority except that which is from God. The authorities that exist have been appointed by God. Consequently, whoever resists authority is opposing what God has set in place, and those who do so will bring judgment on themselves.” Meanwhile, Acts 5:29 states, “But Peter and the other apostles replied: ‘We must obey God rather than men.’” These two passages raise the question of how Christians should approach government mandates, especially when conflict arises between human laws and God’s commands. The biblical record demonstrates both a principle of submission to lawful authorities and the responsibility to resist when obedience to God is at stake. The principles below aim to provide a comprehensive overview of how these verses work together and how believers might apply them. II. The Biblical Mandate for Submission 1. Governing Authorities Are Ordained by God In Romans 13:1, government authorities are depicted as part of God’s order. According to the text, God appoints leaders to maintain stability and justice within societies, allowing for social order and reducing chaos. This concept is reflected throughout Scripture, including 1 Peter 2:13–14, where believers are urged to “submit yourselves for the Lord’s sake to every human institution.” 2. Encouraging Peaceful Coexistence When Paul wrote Romans, Christians were a minority community under Roman rule. Historical sources such as the writings of Tacitus and Josephus illustrate that the governing structures in first-century Rome were often harsh toward new religious movements. Despite these conditions, early Christians were advised to respect the law to maintain peace (see 1 Timothy 2:1–2) and display a God-centered integrity that would win respect, even among non-believers. 3. Practical Benefits of Compliance Submission to just laws can encourage public welfare, protect the vulnerable, and reduce hostility. This principle finds evidence in early Christian documents like the Epistle to Diognetus, which shows how believers living morally within their societies were able to influence their neighbors positively without incurring unnecessary persecution. III. The Command to Obey God Above All 1. When Human Law Conflicts with God’s Law Acts 5:29 is foundational in determining that God’s authority takes precedence over human regulations. In that context, the apostles were commanded to cease preaching Jesus as the risen Messiah, which conflicted with Christ’s commission (see Matthew 28:19–20). Their refusal to comply addressed a direct contradiction: obeying human authorities would have meant disobeying God’s clearest instructions. 2. Historical and Biblical Examples of Faith-Fueled Resistance • Hebrew Midwives (Exodus 1:15–21): They defied Pharaoh’s edict to kill Israelite babies, honoring God’s moral law above society’s brutal command. • Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednego (Daniel 3): They refused to worship an idol instituted by King Nebuchadnezzar and were miraculously preserved by God. • Daniel (Daniel 6): He broke a royal decree prohibiting prayer to anyone other than the king. Daniel continued to pray to God, demonstrating that obedience to God remains paramount. These accounts underscore that obedience to authorities is never absolute when such obedience leads to violating God’s direct commands. 3. Underscoring Christian Witness The apostles in Acts boldly continued preaching out of loyalty to Christ. This unwavering faith and commitment dramatically impacted their world and resulted in spiritual growth despite government opposition. Arriving centuries later, Tertullian famously wrote, “The blood of the martyrs is the seed of the Church,” referencing how faithful commitment, even in the face of government opposition, advanced the message of salvation. IV. Reconciling Romans 13:1–2 with Acts 5:29 1. General Principle vs. Exceptional Circumstance Paul’s teaching in Romans 13 is a general instruction for believers to live peaceably under lawful rule. It guides Christians to support just authorities and be law-abiding citizens. Acts 5:29 speaks to an exceptional circumstance: when a government directive conflicts with clear, core commands from God. One does not invalidate the other; instead, they form two parts of a unified scriptural teaching. 2. Maintaining a Heart of Respect Even in instances of civil disobedience, Scripture advocates an attitude of respect. Daniel’s refusal to obey the king’s edict was not an act of disrespect or rebellion for personal gain; his actions reflected a holy reverence for God’s supreme authority. Similarly, the apostles showed respect for the governing authorities even while saying, “We must obey God rather than men.” Therefore, resisting a law does not equate to hostility or contempt toward the entire government system but is a focused response of faithful adherence to God’s revealed will. 3. Seeking Peace Whenever Possible Believers are urged in Romans 12:18: “If it is possible on your part, live at peace with everyone.” This implies that Christians should pursue compliance with regulations that do not contradict God’s moral or direct commands. When conflict arises, the priority remains fidelity to God’s Word, but always done with humility, prayer, and a heart inclined toward peace. V. Practical Application and Discernment 1. Testing the Nature of the Law Christians can ask: “Does this law demand violating a command of God or hinder the commission of the gospel?” Many laws—traffic regulations, tax requirements, and similar ordinances—do not violate biblical principles. In such cases, obedience exemplifies the believer’s desire to honor God and promote societal well-being. 2. Guided by Prayer and Scripture When questions arise about the morality of a government directive, prayerful study of Scripture and seeking wise counsel within one’s faith community are essential. Proverbs 11:14 states, “For lack of guidance, a nation falls, but with many counselors there is deliverance.” Consulting spiritual leaders and peers can help confirm whether the issue at hand genuinely conflicts with clear biblical mandates. 3. Maintaining a Gospel-Centered Persona Regardless of the stance Christians take—whether obeying just laws or respectfully refusing unrighteous ones—their ultimate goal is to reflect God’s character. A gracious witness can have a profound effect, as shown in the early centuries of Christianity. Archaeological and historical evidence, such as Pliny the Younger’s correspondence with Emperor Trajan, attests to the remarkable growth of the church even under suspicion and intermittent persecution, suggesting that peaceful conduct coupled with unwavering devotion can win hearts. VI. Conclusion Christians are indeed called to obey the government, as governments are established to maintain order and administer justice. Yet Scripture also clearly teaches that any law contradicting God’s commands must yield to divine authority. This tension does not result in contradiction but underscores the multifaceted nature of a believer’s conduct in society. By carefully balancing Romans 13:1–2 with Acts 5:29, followers honor both God’s institution of civil governance and His supreme lordship. Their obedient, respectful posture fosters social stability, while their unwavering commitment to God’s higher law preserves the integrity of their faith. This biblical tension continues to guide believers, leading them to discern, through prayer and Scripture, how to walk faithfully in every circumstance they encounter. |
    |