What are the "not good" statutes in Ezekiel 20:25? I. Introduction to Ezekiel 20:25 Ezekiel 20:25 is a verse that has prompted considerable discussion regarding the meaning of the “not good” statutes. The prophet addresses the Israelites’ history of rebellion, idolatry, and disregard for divine commands. In this context, the passage depicts a situation where God “gave them over” to regulations or practices that would ultimately bring consequences upon them. A brief excerpt from Ezekiel 20:25 states: “So I also gave them over to statutes that were not good…” This signals a dramatic moment in biblical narrative and raises questions about God’s character, justice, and the covenant relationship with Israel. Below is a comprehensive analysis of the historical, literary, and theological context to clarify why such “statutes” are described as “not good.” II. Literary Context in Ezekiel 20 A. Setting and Structure Ezekiel 20 is an extended prophetic discourse directed toward Israel’s elders, who come to Ezekiel to inquire of the Lord. Their history of disobedience is recounted in stages: the exodus from Egypt, the wandering in the wilderness, and ultimately the occupation of the promised land. Each cycle highlights Israel’s failure to live in accordance with God’s commands. B. God’s Permissive Judgment Within this broader narrative, Ezekiel 20:25 arises during a section revealing that God, in response to Israel’s persistent rebellion, allowed them to adopt “not good” statutes. This is sometimes understood as an act of divine judgment where God permits the people to embrace harmful or idolatrous practices as a consequence of their unwillingness to follow His righteous commands. III. Historical and Cultural Backdrop A. Influence of Pagan Nations The ancient Near East was marked by diverse religious practices, many of which involved idolatry and morally offensive customs—such as child sacrifice (e.g., Molech worship). Archaeological findings in regions surrounding Israel, including the offerings found in Tophet areas, support the prevalence of these pagan rites. When Scripture indicates in Ezekiel 20:25 that God “gave them over,” it aligns with the historical reality of Israelites being entangled in neighboring cultural and religious practices. These were “not good” in the sense that they violated the divine moral law, leading to suffering and estrangement from God. B. The Covenant and its Demands Under the Mosaic Covenant, Israel was called to be set apart by following Yahweh’s statutes, which were righteous and life-sustaining (see Deuteronomy 4–6). However, through repeated warnings and judgments, God signaled that continued rebellion would result in their adoption of the very practices He had condemned. The turning over to “not good” statutes is thus understood as punitive—allowing Israel to reap the results of disobedience. IV. Theological Explanations of the “Not Good” Statutes A. Divine Judgment as Withdrawal One theological explanation sees this verse as an example of God’s judgment by withdrawal—He ceases to restrain the people from their own destructive choices. Similar language appears in passages like Romans 1:24, where God “gave them up to impurity”. The idea is that when individuals or a nation persistently reject God’s good statutes, they eventually fall under harmful influences. B. Contrast with God’s Good Law Elsewhere, divine law is declared “good.” For instance, Psalm 119 celebrates God’s commands, and Paul calls the law “holy, righteous, and good” (cf. Romans 7:12). Therefore, these “not good” statutes in Ezekiel 20:25 cannot refer to God’s true commandments, which are always morally perfect. Instead, they must refer to something fundamentally opposed to His character—either the corrupt teachings of paganism or the misapplication of God’s statutes in a twisted manner. V. Interpretations Through Scriptural Harmony A. Cross-Referencing Old Testament Laws Scripture consistently emphasizes that God’s laws are intended for the welfare of His people (cf. Deuteronomy 10:13). Hence, calling a statute “not good” indicates something different from what God originally gave. Many scholars note that these “not good” ordinances resemble the sacrificial rites of Canaanite religions or the perverse additions that Israel introduced, such as child sacrifice (Ezekiel 20:31). B. Consequences of Rebellion Ezekiel 20 portrays God’s patience and repeated calls to repentance. When met with persistent rebellion, He allows them to experience the full consequences of their choices—enacting statutes or following rules that bring suffering rather than blessing. This principle appears throughout biblical narratives, especially in the cyclical pattern of sin, judgment, repentance, and restoration we see in the Book of Judges. VI. Possible Explanations from Hebrew Wording and Structure A. The Phrase “Gave Them Over” The Hebrew verb often translated as “gave” or “delivered” can carry the connotation of handing someone to the power or jurisdiction of another. Hence, in Ezekiel 20:25, God hands rebellious Israel over to the power of destructive practices—essentially letting them sink into the influences they have chosen, which are incompatible with life and blessing. B. The Function of Negative Contrast Ezekiel employs stark imagery and hyperbole to jolt the people out of idolatrous stupor. By calling these regulations “not good,” God underscores the difference between His commandments (which lead to life) and the self-chosen paths leading to death. This negative contrast enforces the lesson that deviation from true worship inevitably ends in ruin. VII. New Testament Corroboration A. Human Hardness of Heart In line with the teaching of Jesus and the apostles, individuals who resist truth can experience a hardening of their hearts (Mark 3:5; Hebrews 3:13). This resonates with the condition described in Ezekiel 20:25. The “not good” statutes highlight how persistent rebellion can lead to being left to one’s own devices. B. The Greater Revelation in Christ When viewed through the lens of the New Testament, this passage in Ezekiel points to humanity’s need for a redemptive solution beyond human capacity. According to the consistent message of Scripture, this redemption is found in Christ’s sacrificial death and resurrection, bringing life to those who were formerly in bondage to destructive ways. VIII. Applicational Insights A. The Warning Against Idolatry Ezekiel 20:25 warns that idolatry and rejection of God’s commands do not lead to freedom but to enslavement under dangerous religious and moral systems. When people deliberately choose ways contrary to God’s character, they suffer the ramifications of their choice. B. The Importance of Discernment Believers today are still called to distinguish between God’s life-giving commands and any cultural or self-made rules that lead to spiritual harm. Being guided by Scripture, illuminated by the Spirit, remains crucial to avoid veering into unhealthy or “not good” beliefs and practices. IX. Summary of Key Points 1. The “not good” statutes in Ezekiel 20:25 do not refer to God’s genuine commandments but to pagan influences or corrupted practices that God allowed rebellious Israel to adopt. 2. Historically and archaeologically, evidence of child sacrifice and other harmful rituals in the ancient Near East underscores the reality of these “not good” statutes. 3. Theologically, this passage highlights God’s righteous judgment, warning that persistent defiance leads to being “given over” to negative consequences. 4. The broader context of Ezekiel 20 and parallel teachings in Scripture clarify that God’s laws are always beneficial; the “not good” statutes are a reflection of Israel’s rejection of His truth. 5. New Testament teachings affirm that humanity desperately needs the salvation offered by Christ, who rescues sinners from sin’s destructive power. X. Conclusion Ezekiel 20:25 exemplifies the sobering reality that when people harden themselves against God’s righteous will, they may be permitted to follow harmful, “not good” rules or practices. Yet, Scripture continuously portrays the Creator’s heart as longing for repentance and restoration. Throughout the Israelite narrative and culminating in Christ’s work, God offers life and blessing through His genuine commandments, contrasting starkly with statutes that only bring judgment and pain. For readers today, Ezekiel 20:25 serves both as a caution and an invitation—warning against paths that lead away from God and toward destruction, and beckoning all to embrace the life and hope found in His true and good commands. |
    |