Genesis 37:28: Human nature, jealousy?
What does Genesis 37:28 reveal about human nature and jealousy?

Genesis 37:28

“Then as the Midianite merchants passed by, his brothers pulled Joseph out of the cistern, sold him for twenty shekels of silver to the Ishmaelites who took him to Egypt.”


Immediate Narrative Setting

Joseph’s brothers, already nursing resentment over his favored status and prophetic dreams (Genesis 37:3–11), act on long-simmering jealousy. The pit that was meant to hide a murder becomes a marketplace of betrayal. Twenty shekels—approximately two years’ wages for a shepherd—puts a monetary value on their envy.


Jealousy as a Catalyst for Sin

Jealousy begins internally (James 3:14–16) yet swiftly externalizes into tangible harm. The brothers’ comparison with Joseph (“our father loves him more”) morphs into covetous anger, then deliberated violence, then trafficking. Genesis 4:5–8 records Cain’s similar slide; Acts 7:9 later confirms, “The patriarchs, jealous of Joseph, sold him into Egypt.” Jealousy, untreated, escalates.


Human Nature and Total Depravity

This episode exposes the corruption of the heart post-Fall (Jeremiah 17:9). Familial bonds, moral upbringing, and covenant heritage cannot restrain sin unaided. Paul’s analysis in Romans 1:29 lists “envy” among sins that flow from an unregenerate mind. The brothers are illustrative, not exceptional.


Collective Complicity and Groupthink

Reuben’s weak protest and Judah’s profit-driven alternative show how group dynamics can normalize evil (Proverbs 1:10–15). Modern behavioral research on diffusion of responsibility mirrors the text: individuals commit acts in groups they would resist alone. Scripture anticipated this social psychology long before contemporary studies.


Objectification Through Commerce

Reducing Joseph to a commodity exposes a utilitarian impulse in fallen mankind. Human trafficking, still prevalent today, is rooted in the same valuation calculus—people as profit (1 Timothy 6:10). The twenty-shekel price echoes Zechariah 11:12 and Matthew 26:15 (thirty pieces) where betrayal is likewise monetized.


Divine Providence Amid Human Sin

Genesis 50:20 records Joseph’s retrospective: “You intended evil against me, but God intended it for good.” Human jealousy cannot thwart God’s sovereign purposes (Romans 8:28). The selling of Joseph becomes the means of Israel’s preservation and the typological groundwork for Christ’s redemptive betrayal.


Foreshadowing of Christ’s Rejection

Joseph, beloved of his father, betrayed by his brothers, sold for silver, and ultimately exalted, prefigures Jesus (Psalm 118:22). The pattern underscores that human jealousy often targets the righteous (Mark 15:10, Pilate recognizing the chief priests’ envy). The narrative bridges testaments, affirming Scripture’s unity.


Archaeological and Textual Notes

Mari tablets (18th c. B.C.) document Midianite/Ishmaelite caravans carrying balm and myrrh from Gilead to Egypt—precisely the trade route in Genesis 37:25. Egyptian execration texts mention “Shu-asu” nomads, likely Midianites, corroborating the historicity of nomadic commerce near Joseph’s timeframe (early 2nd millennium B.C.). Manuscript evidence across Masoretic, Samaritan Pentateuch, and Dead Sea Scroll fragments retains identical core wording for Genesis 37:28, underscoring textual stability.


Psychological Profile of Jealousy

Modern cognitive-behavioral studies categorize envy as a maladaptive social comparison producing rumination and aggression. Proverbs 14:30 anticipated the diagnosis: “A tranquil heart is life to the body, but envy is rottenness to the bones.” Both biblical revelation and empirical observation agree on its corrosive effect.


Ethical and Pastoral Applications

1. Examine heart motives (Psalm 139:23–24) when others prosper.

2. Cultivate gratitude and contentment (Philippians 4:11–13).

3. Confront group envy with courageous dissent (Ephesians 5:11).

4. Trust God’s overruling providence when victimized (1 Peter 2:23).

5. Point sufferers and perpetrators alike to the cross, where jealousy’s wages—betrayal and death—were paid and overcome (Colossians 2:14–15).


Conclusion

Genesis 37:28 discloses jealousy’s anatomy: inward comparison, outward violence, and systemic exploitation. It simultaneously showcases the redemptive thread: God weaves even envy-born evil into His salvific tapestry, culminating at Calvary. Human nature is exposed; divine grace is exalted.

Why did Joseph's brothers sell him instead of killing him?
Top of Page
Top of Page