How tall was Goliath according to 1 Samuel 17:4, and is this historically accurate? SCRIPTURAL STATEMENT (1 Samuel 17:4) “Then a champion named Goliath, who was from Gath, came out from the Philistine camp. He was six cubits and a span tall.” Ancient Measurements Clarified • Royal cubit (Heb. ʼammah): ≈ 20.4 – 20.6 in. (52 cm). • Span (zeret): ≈ 8.8 – 9 in. (22 – 23 cm). Six cubits + one span = ~ 9 ft 6 in – 9 ft 9 in (2.9 – 3.0 m). Evaluating The Variant Readings 1. Armor weight (5,000 bronze shekels ≈ 125–150 lb / 57–68 kg) and spear shaft (“like a weaver’s beam,” iron head ≈ 15–17 lb / 7 kg) match a man of extraordinary stature. At ~ 6 ft 9 in the armor is disproportionate, but is fitting for ~ 9 ft 9 in. 2. Deuteronomy 3:11 cites Og’s iron bed at nine cubits (≈ 13.5 ft), placing giant-sized warriors earlier in Israel’s memory; Anakim reputation (Numbers 13:32–33; Joshua 11:21–22) centers around Gath, Goliath’s city. The six-cubit figure harmonizes with that tradition. 3. The shorter reading can arise by parablepsis (eye skip) between the two Hebrew letters representing six (ו) and four (ד) or by harmonization to a less startling height for Greek readers. The longer reading lacks internal motive for expansion. 4. Multiple independent Hebrew traditions (MT, Targums, Peshitta) preserve six cubits; a single Greek recension and one fragmentary DSS text support four. Weight of evidence favors MT. Historical And Archaeological Context • Tell es-Safi (biblical Gath) Ostracon (ca. 10th c. BC) bears two Philistine names “ʼLWT” and “WLT” phonetically close to “Goliath,” confirming name’s authenticity in the right city and century. • Egyptian reliefs of the 19th–20th Dynasties depict Sherden and Philistine Sea Peoples as above-average warriors (often drawn a head taller than Syro-Canaanites). • Skeletal finds: A Late Bronze–Iron I male femur from Ashkelon (Philistine enclave) extrapolates to ~ 6 ft 6 in—already exceptional for the period; pathological gigantism can add 2–3 ft more (cf. modern Robert Wadlow 8 ft 11 in, Sultan Kösen 8 ft 2 in). These demonstrate human genetic potential for extreme height without mythological embellishment. Anthropological Plausibility • Pituitary gigantism occurs at ≈ 3/100,000 births; survival into adulthood is rare today but plausible within small Iron Age populations. • Armor made to a giant’s measure would be prized and preserved; 1 Samuel 21:9 notes Goliath’s sword kept at Nob, aligning with normal Near-Eastern practice of field‐collected relics. Consistency With The Broader Biblical Narrative • Joshua 11:22 – “Only in Gaza, Gath, and Ashdod did any survive.” The survival of Anakim in Gath provides genealogical footing for Goliath and the later giants slain by David’s men (2 Samuel 21:15-22). • 2 Samuel 21:20 describes another giant “with six fingers on each hand” (polydactyly frequently accompanies gigantism), reinforcing the historical portrayal of a surviving remnant of unusually tall Philistines. Historical Accuracy Summation Taking the best-attested reading (“six cubits and a span”), Goliath stood near 9 ft 9 in. Modern medical data confirm that such height, while extraordinary, is physiologically viable. The description is internally coherent (armor weight, spear size), textually supported, archaeologically situated, and consonant with the wider canonical testimony. Theological Implication The accurate preservation of so precise a measurement after three millennia underscores Scripture’s reliability. The episode displays divine deliverance by disproportionate means—foreshadowing salvation accomplished through apparent weakness in the cross and resurrection of Christ (1 Corinthians 1:25-27). Accepting the historicity of Goliath’s stature thus strengthens trust in the God who acts in real space-time and invites all people to faith in His risen Son. |
    |