How do believers discern truth per Jer 28:17?
How should believers discern truth from falsehood in light of Jeremiah 28:17?

Setting the Scene

Jeremiah 28 records a clash between faithful Jeremiah and the self-appointed prophet Hananiah. Hananiah promised quick deliverance from Babylon; Jeremiah, speaking for God, warned of a heavier yoke. Jeremiah 28:17 closes the chapter: “And in that very year, in the seventh month, the prophet Hananiah died.” God’s swift judgment settled who spoke truth.


What Jeremiah 28:17 Teaches Us About Discernment

• God Himself vindicates truth and exposes error.

• Timing matters: Hananiah’s death came “in that very year,” confirming Jeremiah’s earlier word (vv. 15-16).

• Discernment is not merely academic; it protects God’s people from destructive lies.

• False teaching ultimately harms the teacher and hearers; truth preserves both.


Four Marks of False Teaching (Drawn from the Chapter)

1. Promises that appeal to the flesh (“Within two years…” v. 3).

2. Contradiction of prior, established revelation (Jeremiah, Isaiah, Moses).

3. Absence of repentance or call to obedience (compare Jeremiah 26:13).

4. Lack of lasting fruit—culminating in divine judgment (v. 17; cf. Matthew 7:19-20).


Guardrails from the Rest of Scripture

• Compare prophecy with fulfillment — Deuteronomy 18:21-22.

• Examine fruit and character — Matthew 7:15-20.

• Test the spirits — 1 John 4:1.

• Search the Scriptures daily — Acts 17:11.

• Hold to sound doctrine, resisting “itching ears” — 2 Timothy 4:3-4.

• Remember prophecy’s divine origin — 2 Peter 1:19-21.


Practical Steps for Discerning Truth Today

• Stay saturated in Scripture; know the original so counterfeits stand out.

• Weigh new teachings against the whole counsel of God, not isolated verses.

• Observe a teacher’s lifestyle: humility, holiness, and love signal authenticity.

• Look for Christ-exalting, repentant fruit in those influenced.

• Remain accountable within a biblically faithful church community.

• Trust God’s timing; He will ultimately confirm His word, even if exposure of error feels slow.


Living It Out

Jeremiah’s fidelity cost him popularity but saved a remnant. God still calls believers to that same courage—rejecting soothing falsehoods, embracing hard truths, and resting in the certainty that He will, in His perfect timing, vindicate His Word and His faithful servants.

How does Jeremiah 28:17 connect with Deuteronomy 18:20 on false prophets?
Top of Page
Top of Page