What does their response reveal about their understanding of justice and innocence? The Setting Joseph’s steward has overtaken Jacob’s sons, accusing them of stealing his master’s silver cup. Verse 7 records their immediate reply: “Why does my lord say these words? Far be it from your servants to do such a thing”. Immediate Reaction: A Cry of Innocence Their opening words show three things: • They are shocked—“Why does my lord say these words?” suggests the charge feels utterly foreign to them. • They emphatically deny guilt—“Far be it” is a strong Hebrew idiom meaning “may it never happen.” • They still address the steward respectfully—calling him “my lord,” even while protesting, reveals submission to rightful authority. Layers of Their Understanding of Justice 1. Justice requires evidence – They assume justice is anchored in truth, so they ask for clarification rather than lashing out. 2. Innocence deserves protection – Their instinct is to distance themselves from wrongdoing because they believe the innocent should be cleared. 3. Guilt should be unthinkable for covenant people – They see theft as incompatible with their identity as sons of Israel. Compare Exodus 20:15, “You shall not steal.” Even before Sinai, moral law was written on their hearts (Romans 2:14-15). 4. Punishment must match the crime – In verse 9 they volunteer that if any one is found with the cup, “he must die” and the rest “will become my lord’s slaves.” They adopt the lex talionis principle later codified in Exodus 21:23-25. Comparison with Earlier Episodes • Contrast with Genesis 37:31-33 – Years earlier they had deceived Jacob about Joseph’s “death.” Now they claim absolute honesty. Their reply in 44:7 shows growth; they no longer wish to live under false accusations. • Contrast with their treatment of Simeon in Egypt (Genesis 42:21-24) – Their earlier admissions of guilt regarding Joseph (“We are truly guilty…” 42:21) sharpen their sense of justice now. Having tasted remorse, innocence matters more than self-preservation. Broader Biblical Echoes of Justice and Innocence • Deuteronomy 19:15—A matter must be established “by two or three witnesses.” The brothers’ protest anticipates this requirement. • Proverbs 17:15—“He who justifies the wicked and he who condemns the righteous are both detestable to the LORD.” Their stance aligns with God’s hatred of condemning the innocent. • Isaiah 5:20—Calling evil good or good evil perverts justice. Their immediate denial resists any blurring of moral lines. Lessons for Today • Guard a reputation for integrity before false charges arise. • Appeal to truth and evidence, not emotion, when justice is challenged. • Respect authority while seeking vindication—honor and honesty can coexist. • A tender conscience grows from past repentance; earlier sin confessed prepares us to stand firmly for righteousness now. |
    |