Does Psalm 104:5 imply a literal or metaphorical interpretation of Earth's immovability? Verse in Focus “He set the earth on its foundations; it can never be moved.” — Psalm 104:5 Immediate Literary Context Psalm 104 is a hymn paralleling Genesis 1, celebrating God’s creative acts: light (v2), heavens (v2-4), earth (v5-9), vegetation (v14-17), animals (v18-23), and humanity (v23-24). The language is lofty poetry, employing imagery rather than prose narrative. Verses 5–9 describe terrestrial stability, oceans kept within bounds, and mountains rising. The focus is God’s providential order, not a cosmology lesson. Canonical Harmony Other “immovability” texts—Psalm 93:1; 96:10; 1 Chronicles 16:30—use identical vocabulary, always within praise psalms. Conversely, Job 1:19, Psalm 18:7, and Isaiah 24:18 speak of the earth “moving” in earthquakes by the same root מוּט. Scripture therefore uses מוּט idiomatically: moral/creational security versus catastrophic shaking. No contradiction exists when understood as phenomenological language. Ancient Near-Eastern Backdrop ANE hymns (e.g., Ugaritic KTU 1.23) likewise extol gods who “fix the earth.” Yet Israel’s psalmist rejects mythic combat motifs; Yahweh alone, by spoken word, secures creation. Psalm 104:5 subverts pagan cosmology, locating stability in the Creator, not cosmic sea monsters. Patristic and Reformational Commentary • Augustine (Confessions 12.16): “Foundations” signify God’s invisible ordering intellectus, not literal pillars. • John Calvin (Commentary on Psalms): “The Psalmist does not speak in the language of philosophers, but in a popular style.” • Francis Turretin (Institutes 5.8): Earth’s stability is “moral certainty,” compatible with daily rotation. Phenomenological Language Scripture routinely describes things as they appear: sunrise (Psalm 113:3), mustard seed “smallest” (Matthew 13:32), four corners of the earth (Isaiah 11:12). Inerrancy is preserved because the Bible is truthful in what it intends to affirm; here, that creation is upheld by God (Hebrews 1:3). Scientific Corroboration of Stability Without Stasis • Earth’s orbit varies by <3 % annually (perihelion/aphelion), maintaining climate stability essential for life (anthropic fine-tuning). • Magnetic field and axial tilt are held within narrow life-permitting ranges (NASA, 2023 data). Such “immovability” of habitability, not immobility of motion, undergirds the psalmist’s praise. • Catastrophic plate tectonics during the Flood (Genesis 7 – 8) illustrate that God can “shake” the earth (Psalm 18:7) when judging, yet its ordered existence persists. Archaeological and Historical Corroborations • Ebenezer inscription (10th c. BC) lists Yahweh as “Establisher of lands,” parallel to Psalm 104. • Tel Dan Stele uses the verb יָסַד of dynastic stability, showing idiomatic usage. These finds validate contemporaneous linguistic texture. Answer Summarized Psalm 104:5 asserts that God has rendered the earth secure in His sovereign plan; the verse is poetic, phenomenological, and theological, not a scientific declaration of geocentrism. Taking Scripture as inerrant, harmonizing genre, lexicon, and broader canon—and respecting observational science within a young-earth creation framework—leads to a metaphorical understanding of “immovability” regarding position, while affirming literal divine preservation of the planet. |
    |