John 5:12: God's commands vs. man's rules?
What does John 5:12 reveal about obedience to God's commands versus man's rules?

Setting the Scene

Jesus has just healed a man who had been an invalid for thirty-eight years (John 5:1-11). The miracle occurs on the Sabbath, and the man obeys Jesus’ instruction to “Pick up your mat and walk.” Immediately, religious leaders confront him for carrying his mat, an act they interpret as Sabbath work.


John 5:12

“Who told you to pick it up and walk?” they asked.


Man-Made Rules Exposed

• The leaders ignore the healing itself and fixate on their tradition of not carrying objects on the Sabbath (cf. Jeremiah 17:21-22).

• Their question reveals a mindset that elevates human interpretation above divine compassion.

• They show more concern for policing behavior than celebrating God’s power at work.


God’s Commands Highlighted

• The Sabbath command in Exodus 20:8-11 centers on rest and worship, not legalistic minutiae.

Isaiah 58:13-14 underscores delighting in the Lord, not oppressive regulation.

• Jesus’ healing aligns perfectly with the Sabbath’s purpose of restoration and mercy (Matthew 12:10-13).


Key Insights about Obedience

1. Jesus’ word carries higher authority than religious tradition (Mark 7:8-9).

2. True obedience springs from recognizing God’s heart, not merely conforming to man-made fences (1 Samuel 15:22).

3. When man’s rules contradict God’s action or character, believers must obey God rather than men (Acts 5:29).

4. Christ liberates from burdensome ordinances; human additions can enslave (Colossians 2:8, 20-23).

5. Mercy is integral to God’s law; rules that stifle mercy misrepresent Him (Hosea 6:6 quoted in Matthew 12:7).


Practical Takeaways

• Measure every tradition against clear Scripture and the revealed character of God.

• Rejoice when God works, even if it challenges familiar customs.

• Guard your heart from valuing rule-keeping over loving obedience.

• Let Jesus define righteousness; do not let cultural or religious expectations override His voice in Scripture.

How does John 5:12 challenge us to discern authority in our lives?
Top of Page
Top of Page