What does Luke 11:41 mean by "give as alms the things that are within"? Immediate Literary Context Verses 37–42 recount Jesus dining with a Pharisee. The host marvels that Jesus does not perform the customary ceremonial washing (cf. Mark 7:3–4). Jesus answers that the Pharisees “clean the outside of the cup and dish, but inside you are full of greed and wickedness” (v. 39). The contrast sets up v. 41: the solution to inner corruption is not more external washings but genuine generosity flowing from a transformed heart. Cultural–Historical Background: Pharisaic Purity Practices First-century Pharisees developed detailed oral laws (later codified in the Mishnah, Tractate Yadayim) governing ritual hand-washing and vessel purity. Archaeological finds of stone vessels around Jerusalem (e.g., excavations in the Priest’s Quarter) illustrate the concern to avoid Levitical impurity (cf. Leviticus 11–15). Jesus does not dismiss ceremonial law per se (Matthew 5:17) but exposes hypocrisy when ritual replaces righteousness. Synoptic Parallel Matthew 23:25-26: “First clean the inside of the cup and dish, so that the outside may also become clean.” Luke sharpens Matthew’s imperative: inner cleansing occurs through concrete almsgiving. Old Testament Foundations of Almsgiving • Deuteronomy 15:7-11—open hand to the poor. • Proverbs 19:17—“Whoever is kind to the poor lends to the LORD.” • Isaiah 58:6-9—true fasting involves feeding the hungry; then “your righteousness shall go before you.” • Ezekiel 36:26—new heart promised; generosity evidences this renewal. Second-Temple Jewish Voice Tobit 4:11; Sirach 3:30 celebrate alms as atonement. While these texts are Deuterocanonical, they display the milieu: charity was viewed as cleansing. Jesus affirms the principle yet roots its efficacy in an authentic heart, not a meritorious work. Early Church Exposition • Chrysostom: “Pour out your riches upon the poor; you will wash the cup within.” • Augustine: “Alms proceed from inward love; thus the giver himself is purified.” Theological Significance 1. Justification and Evidence—Alms do not purchase forgiveness (Ephesians 2:8-9) but testify that the heart has been regenerated by grace (Titus 2:14). 2. Sanctification—Generosity disciplines the soul against greed (1 Timothy 6:17-19). 3. Holiness Paradigm—Purity begins in the inner man (Psalm 51:6), manifests outwardly (James 1:27). Practical Application • Self-Examination: Invite the Spirit (Psalm 139:23-24) to expose inner greed. • Concrete Mercy: Budget regular, sacrificial giving; share meals, not merely money. • Holistic Cleansing: Couple doctrinal fidelity with tangible compassion; the two are inseparable marks of authentic faith (1 John 3:17-18). Conclusion “Give as alms the things that are within” summons hearers to let inner transformation burst forth in generous mercy. When the heart relinquishes greed through Spirit-empowered charity, “everything will be clean.” The cup’s interior—our motives—becomes pure, and the exterior—our actions—follows suit, fulfilling the Creator’s design that His image-bearers reflect His benevolent holiness. |
    |