What role do Pharisees play in the debate over Gentile circumcision in Acts 15:5? Setting the Scene in Jerusalem • After Paul and Barnabas’ first missionary journey, Gentile believers were flooding into the churches. • A dispute arose when some from Judea insisted that these Gentiles must be circumcised to be saved (Acts 15:1). • The church in Antioch sent Paul, Barnabas, and others to Jerusalem for guidance from the apostles and elders (Acts 15:2–4). Who Are These Pharisees? • Acts 15:5 pinpoints the source of the pushback: “But some believers from the party of the Pharisees stood up and said, ‘It is necessary to circumcise them and to command them to keep the Law of Moses.’ ” • These men are described as “believers,” indicating genuine faith in Christ, yet they retained their Pharisaic training and commitment to the Mosaic Law. • Their background: Pharisees were devoted to meticulous obedience (Acts 26:5; Matthew 23:23), so they naturally viewed circumcision—God’s covenant sign with Abraham (Genesis 17:9–14)—as non-negotiable. Their Specific Demand 1. Circumcision for Gentile converts. 2. Ongoing obedience to the full Law of Moses. • In their minds, salvation and covenant membership still required the visible sign given to Israel. • They feared that removing circumcision would weaken Scripture’s authority and blur Israel’s identity. Why They Spoke Up • Zeal for Scripture: They read Genesis 17 literally and could not imagine God setting aside that eternal covenant sign. • Concern for purity: Allowing uncircumcised Gentiles into fellowship felt like compromising holiness (cf. Exodus 12:48). • Tradition’s weight: Years of rabbinic teaching reinforced the belief that circumcision marked true sons of Abraham (John 8:33). How the Council Answered • Peter testified that God gave the Holy Spirit to uncircumcised Gentiles, “making no distinction between us and them” (Acts 15:8–9). • Barnabas and Paul recounted signs and wonders among Gentiles apart from circumcision (Acts 15:12). • James affirmed prophecy: “The rest of mankind may seek the Lord— even all the Gentiles who bear My name” (Acts 15:17, citing Amos 9:11–12). • Final decision: No circumcision requirement—only a short list to foster table fellowship (Acts 15:19–20, 28–29). Lessons from Their Role • Sincere believers can disagree strongly yet submit to apostolic authority. • Tradition, however cherished, must bow to the fresh revelation God gives through Scripture and the Spirit. • The gospel is grace-based, not ceremony-based; adding requirements obscures the sufficiency of Christ (Galatians 5:2–4). • The Pharisee believers, by voicing their concerns, prompted a clear doctrinal statement that still guards the church today. |
    |