How does Romans 6:20 challenge the concept of free will in Christianity? Immediate Context in Romans 6 Paul has just shown that union with the risen Christ liberates believers from sin’s dominion (vv. 1–14) and transfers them to slavery under righteousness (vv. 15–23). Verse 20 sums up the unregenerate state: total incapacity to live righteously. The antithesis is deliberate: one is either a slave of sin or of Christ—no neutral ground. Historic Christian Definitions of Free Will 1. Libertarian Freedom: the power to choose contrary to any prior inclination. 2. Compatibilist Freedom: the power to act according to one’s strongest desire, yet those desires flow from nature. Romans 6:20 is difficult for the libertarian model; it coheres with the compatibilist model long taught by Augustine, Aquinas, Calvin, Edwards, and echoed in modern analytical philosophy. Pauline Anthropology: Enslavement to Sin Scripture presents pre-conversion humanity as morally dead (Ephesians 2:1), captive (2 Timothy 2:26), and blinded (2 Corinthians 4:4). Jesus said, “Everyone who sins is a slave to sin” (John 8:34). Romans 3:9-18 strings OT citations to prove universal bondage. Hence, Romans 6:20 is part of a consistent biblical testimony that the will is not morally neutral. How Romans 6:20 Challenges Autonomous Free Will 1. The verse labels unbelievers “slaves,” a term that in first-century Rome denoted zero legal self-determination. 2. Being “free” from righteousness is not a positive liberty but an inability to produce it. 3. The text therefore rejects the premise that fallen humans can, unaided, choose genuine righteousness. Two Mutually Exclusive Slaveries Paul’s binary—sin or righteousness—parallels Jesus’ “No one can serve two masters” (Matthew 6:24). Freedom from sin is not self-generated; it is received (Romans 6:22). Thus, free will is real but derivative, exercised only because grace first changes the heart (John 6:44). Implications for Human Ability and Accountability While the unregenerate cannot please God (Romans 8:7-8), they remain accountable because willful rebellion flows from their own desires (James 1:14). Divine justice is upheld: bondage does not erase culpability. Philosophical Antecedents Augustine’s fourfold state (able to sin, not able not to sin, able not to sin, unable to sin) clarifies that post-Fall humanity sits in the second category. Luther’s “Bondage of the Will” (1525) cites Romans 6 repeatedly, arguing that true freedom is conferred only through regeneration. Connection to the Resurrection The same power that raised Jesus (Romans 6:4; 8:11) re-creates the believer’s will. The empty tomb, attested by multiple early independent sources (1 Corinthians 15:3-8; Acts; Mark 16; Matthew 28) and accepted by 75% of critical scholars (Habermas 2012 survey), undergirds the claim that new existential freedom is possible. Archaeological and Manuscript Corroboration Papyrus 46 (c. AD 175), containing Romans, confirms the text’s stability within a century of authorship. The 1998 discovery of inscriptional evidence for “synagogē of the Freedmen” in Rome corroborates Paul’s social backdrop of slavery language. Such finds reinforce confidence that we are reading Paul’s authentic words. Compatibilism and Evangelism Recognizing bondage clarifies evangelistic method: proclaim the gospel (Romans 10:17), trusting the Spirit to grant repentance (2 Timothy 2:25). Anecdotally, John Newton—former slave trader turned hymn writer—testified, “I once was lost, but now am found; was blind, but now I see,” illustrating the experiential shift Romans 6 describes. Practical Application 1. Humility: recognize innate inability. 2. Dependency: seek the Spirit’s power daily. 3. Assurance: believers now have “the obedience of faith” (Romans 1:5). 4. Evangelism: stress both responsibility and grace—“Whoever calls on the name of the Lord will be saved” (Romans 10:13). Conclusion Romans 6:20 dismantles the idea of autonomous, morally neutral free will. Human will exists, yet it operates in bondage until liberated by Christ’s resurrection power. Far from diminishing responsibility, this truth magnifies grace and fuels worship of the God who alone sets captives free. |
    |