What is the meaning of 1 Samuel 29:5? Is this not the David ‒ The Philistine commanders immediately recognize David’s identity. He is not an obscure Hebrew mercenary but the champion who toppled Goliath (1 Samuel 17:45–50) and whose name had become synonymous with victory (1 Samuel 18:30). ‒ Their question drips with alarm: “Is this not the David…?” They are reminding King Achish that the very man he trusts is the same man who once devastated Philistine forces (1 Samuel 21:11) and escaped Saul’s traps with God’s favor (1 Samuel 23:14). ‒ In context (1 Samuel 29:1–4), they fear David will turn on them in battle, regain Saul’s approval, and leave Philistine ranks in ruins. About whom they sing in their dances ‒ Israel’s victory songs were public and memorable (1 Samuel 18:6–7). Joyful dancing accompanied triumph, just as Miriam led Israel in song after the Red Sea (Exodus 15:20–21) and Jephthah’s daughter greeted her father with tambourines (Judges 11:34). ‒ Such celebrations fixed David’s exploits in the collective memory of both Israel and her enemies. The Philistines could not forget the jubilant processions that heralded their own defeats. ‒ Their recollection shows how fully David’s reputation had spread beyond Israel’s borders, making even pagan soldiers wary of him. Saul has slain his thousands ‒ The first half of the refrain honors Saul’s genuine military success: he rescued Jabesh-gilead (1 Samuel 11:11), waged campaigns against surrounding nations (1 Samuel 14:47–48), and struck Amalek (1 Samuel 15:4–8). ‒ Yet the song subtly signals Saul’s limitations—“thousands,” not “tens of thousands.” This contrast fed Saul’s jealousy (1 Samuel 18:8–9) and foreshadowed his decline. ‒ For the Philistines, the line reminds them that even a formidable king like Saul could not secure ultimate victory when David was on the field. And David his tens of thousands ‒ Hyperbolic or not, the phrase captures David’s astonishing string of wins: Goliath’s defeat (1 Samuel 17:50–53), repeated raids that “struck down the Philistines with great slaughter” (1 Samuel 19:8), and relentless success that made his name “highly esteemed” (1 Samuel 18:30). ‒ The lyric places David in a class of his own, eclipsing Saul and striking fear into enemy hearts—exactly what happens here in Gath (1 Samuel 29:4–5). ‒ By recalling this chant, the Philistines admit they believe the Lord who empowered David then could empower him now, turning the tide against them in an instant (compare 2 Samuel 5:2; 7:9). summary 1 Samuel 29:5 records the Philistine commanders’ uneasy memory of Israel’s famous victory song. Each phrase underscores David’s God-given reputation: the recognized warrior (“Is this not the David”), the celebrated hero of Israelite worship (“about whom they sing in their dances”), the contrast with Saul’s lesser exploits (“Saul has slain his thousands”), and the superlative measure of David’s triumphs (“and David his tens of thousands”). In context, the verse explains why the Philistines demand David’s dismissal from their ranks: they believe the same Lord who once gave him overwhelming victories could again turn him into their destroyer. The verse therefore highlights both David’s unmatched military record and the sovereign power of God that stands behind it. |
    |