Why did David refuse to drink the water from 2 Samuel 23:17? Setting the Scene 2 Samuel 23:15–17 describes three of David’s mighty men slipping through the Philistine lines at Bethlehem to draw water for their king. When they return, “He would not drink it, but poured it out to the LORD” (v. 16). Verse 17 records David’s words: “Far be it from me, O LORD, that I should do this! Is this not the blood of the men who went at the risk of their lives? So he would not drink it. Such were the exploits of the three mighty men.” Why David Refused the Water • He equated the water with the lifeblood of his men. – Leviticus 17:11: “the life of the flesh is in the blood.” – By risking death, they had, in effect, poured out their lives. • Drinking it would have trivialized their sacrifice—treating a life-threatening gift as ordinary refreshment. • His conscience, sensitive to God’s law and the value of human life, recoiled at the idea of personal indulgence gained at such a price. • He viewed the act as belonging to God alone; only the LORD was worthy of that level of devotion. David’s Alternative: A Pouring Out to the LORD • David turned the water into a drink offering, symbolically returning the men’s sacrifice to God. • By pouring it out, he honored both the LORD and the men: – Recognizing God as the ultimate recipient of valor (1 Samuel 17:47). – Acknowledging that the men’s courage was an act of worship, not simply loyalty to a human king. • Parallels: 1 Chronicles 11:19 repeats the account, underscoring its importance. Key Lessons • True leadership values people over personal comfort. • Sacrificial gifts meant for God must never be consumed on self (cf. 1 Samuel 2:12–17 for the opposite example). • Honor is shown not only by receiving gifts but sometimes by refusing them when acceptance would diminish their sacredness. • Every act of courage offered for God’s purposes is ultimately an offering to Him (Romans 12:1). Living It Out Today • Evaluate comforts that come at others’ expense—are they fit for self-indulgence or should they be redirected to God’s glory? • Cultivate a conscience that instantly recognizes when something costly to others must be treated as holy. • Celebrate and protect the sacrifices of fellow believers, ensuring they point back to the LORD rather than to us. |
    |