Why did Joseph try to correct Jacob's blessing in Genesis 48:17? The Setting: An Aged Patriarch and Two Grandsons • Genesis 48 sets the scene: Jacob, near death, adopts Joseph’s sons—Manasseh (firstborn) and Ephraim (younger)—as his own, placing them on equal footing with Reuben and Simeon (Genesis 48:5). • Tradition dictated that the right hand symbolized the pre-eminent blessing reserved for the firstborn (cf. Deuteronomy 21:17). • Joseph carefully positions the boys so Jacob’s right hand will fall on Manasseh (Genesis 48:12-13). Joseph’s Concern in Genesis 48:17 “ When Joseph saw that his father had placed his right hand on Ephraim’s head, he was displeased; so he took his father’s hand to move it from Ephraim’s head to Manasseh’s.” Why Joseph steps in: • Cultural responsibility – As the family’s prime minister in Egypt, Joseph feels duty-bound to uphold the God-given order of the firstborn blessing. • Honor for Manasseh – Joseph named his first son Manasseh, testifying, “God has made me forget all my hardship” (Genesis 41:51). Joseph naturally wants that son to carry the greater honor. • Assumption of an error – Jacob’s eyesight is failing (Genesis 48:10). Joseph thinks the crossed hands are accidental, not intentional. • Desire for clarity and fairness – With tribal inheritances at stake, Joseph wants the distribution unmistakably clear before Jacob dies. Jacob’s Intentional Crossed Hands • Jacob refuses the correction: “I know, my son, I know… his younger brother will be greater” (Genesis 48:19). • God’s sovereign pattern repeats: – Isaac over Ishmael (Genesis 17:18-21) – Jacob over Esau (Genesis 25:23) – Judah over his older brothers (Genesis 49:8-10) • The blessing is prophetic, not merely preferential; Ephraim will indeed become the dominant northern tribe (Numbers 1:32-33; Hosea 11:8-9). What Joseph Learns Through the Incident • God’s purposes surpass human custom—He reserves the right to exalt the humble and reshape expectations (1 Samuel 16:6-12; Luke 14:11). • True blessing comes from divine choice, not birth order or human strategy (Romans 9:10-13). • Joseph must trust the same sovereign hand that guided his own life (Genesis 50:20). Summing Up: Why Joseph Tried to Correct Jacob Joseph intervened because he believed the firstborn, Manasseh, deserved the primary blessing and assumed his dim-sighted father had erred. Jacob’s deliberate cross-handed act, however, revealed God’s sovereign selection of Ephraim, teaching that divine purpose, not tradition, ultimately determines blessing and destiny. |
    |