Why did Joseph place the silver cup in Benjamin's sack in Genesis 44:2? The narrative setup Genesis 44:2: “Put my cup—the silver one—in the mouth of the youngest one’s sack, along with the silver for his grain.” Why Joseph orchestrated this surprise • Echo of the past: Benjamin now stands where Joseph once stood—as the favored youngest son. Joseph recreates the earlier jealousy scenario (cf. Genesis 37:3–4) to see whether the brothers will again sacrifice the favored brother for their own safety. • Heart-test of repentance: Joseph has already probed them (Genesis 42:15, 20). The cup episode becomes the decisive test: will they abandon Benjamin or protect him? • Pathway to reconciliation: By compelling the brothers to return, Joseph positions himself to reveal his identity and extend forgiveness (Genesis 45:1–5). • Preservation of the family: Keeping Benjamin close ensures Jacob’s sons stay together in Egypt, the place God will use to sustain them through famine (Genesis 45:7–11). • Sovereign orchestration: Psalm 105:17-19 recalls that God “sent a man before them—Joseph.” The cup episode is one more link in God’s providential chain, moving the covenant family toward its promised future. Evidence of genuine change Judah’s speech (Genesis 44:18-34) highlights what Joseph hoped to see: - Acknowledgment of guilt (“God has uncovered your servants’ iniquity,” v. 16). - Willingness to stand in for Benjamin (v. 33). - Concern for their father’s grief (v. 30-31). Take-aways for today • True repentance shows itself in changed behavior, not merely words (cf. 2 Corinthians 7:10-11). • God sometimes arranges unsettling tests to reveal what is hidden and to heal what is broken (James 1:2-4). • Forgiveness and reconciliation often require a moment of truth that brings sin into the light (Luke 17:3-4). In summary Joseph’s placement of the silver cup was a calculated test designed to expose his brothers’ hearts, secure Benjamin’s safety, and set the stage for family restoration—demonstrating God’s faithful, purposeful hand at every turn. |
    |