Why does Jesus warn against following those who say "Look, here He is" in Luke 17:23? Key Verse Luke 17:23 – “People will tell you, ‘Look, there He is!’ or ‘Look, here He is!’ Do not go out or chase after them.” Immediate Literary Setting Jesus has just answered the Pharisees’ question “When will the kingdom of God come?” (v. 20). He teaches that the kingdom is “in your midst” (v. 21) because the King Himself is present. He then turns to His disciples (v. 22) and tells them hard days are ahead when they will “long to see one of the days of the Son of Man.” In that emotional vulnerability counterfeit voices will say, “Look, here He is,” offering a quick fix to suffering. The warning comes precisely to shield the disciples from misplaced hope and ensuing despair. Old Testament Backdrop: Tests for Truth-Claims Deuteronomy 13:1-4 and 18:20-22 command Israel to reject prophets whose message or morals contradict Yahweh’s revelation. Jesus’ prohibition echoes that canonical filter. Any voice urging relocation to find Messiah breaks continuity with God’s program, for true redemption comes to Zion from Yahweh Himself (Isaiah 59:20). Synoptic Parallels and Unity of Teaching Matthew 24:23-27 and Mark 13:21-23 repeat the warning almost verbatim, coupling it with the global, lightning-like visibility of the genuine Parousia. The three witnesses agree: a geographically limited “Messiah sighting” is immediately disqualified. Historical Fulfilments of the False-Messiah Phenomenon • Acts 5:36-37 mentions Theudas and Judas the Galilean. • Josephus, Jewish War 2.259-263, 6.285-288, records “sign prophets” and impostors who lured thousands into the desert with claims of deliverance. • Simon bar Kokhba (A.D. 132-135) was hailed as “King Messiah,” costing Israel 580,000 lives. These episodes verify Jesus’ foresight and illustrate why chasing claims is deadly. Theological Core: The Unmistakable Parousia 1. Universality – “as the lightning flashes…so will the Son of Man be in His day” (Luke 17:24). No one will need directions. 2. Sovereign Timing – the Son of Man must first “suffer many things” (v. 25). Any Messiah who bypasses the cross is counterfeit. 3. Cosmic Accompaniment – trumpet, archangel, resurrection (1 Thessalonians 4:16-17). These global-scale events cannot be staged. Kingdom Presence versus Geographic Pilgrimage By calling the kingdom “in your midst” (ἐντὸς ὑμῶν), Jesus shifts focus from a place to a Person. He dismantles the ancient Near-Eastern belief that deities are tied to sacred spaces. Since the incarnate King dwells with His people (John 1:14; Revelation 21:3), traveling to hunt Him is theological regression. Pastoral and Behavioral Dynamics Humans in crisis show heightened gullibility (behavioral science term: “need for closure”). Jesus pre-emptively addresses that vulnerability. False Christs promise immediate relief, bypassing repentance. The admonition “Do not go out” functions as a safeguard for emotional resilience and doctrinal fidelity. Eschatological Framework: Already and Not-Yet The kingdom is present (“already”) in regenerating power, yet future (“not-yet”) in climactic manifestation. Jesus’ warning prevents confusion between these phases. Premature localization mutates the hope of glory into an earthbound spectacle. Practical Discernment for the Contemporary Church • Test every spirit by Christological confession (1 John 4:1-3). • Weigh claims against the whole counsel of Scripture; the final authority is not charisma but canon. • Anchor evangelism in the finished work of the risen Lord, not in sensational geography. • Cultivate watchfulness through Word and prayer, not fear-driven pilgrimage. Concluding Synthesis Jesus forbids chasing voices that locate Him in a particular spot because the genuine return will be public, incontrovertible, cross-validated by prior suffering, and globally visible. The warning guards against deception, preserves doctrinal purity, and directs hope away from human showmen to the triumphant Son of Man whose appearance will overwhelm the horizon like lightning and usher in irreversible glory. |
    |