Why does Deuteronomy 12:8 emphasize not doing "as we are doing here today"? Canonical Text and Immediate Context Deuteronomy 12:8–9 : “You are not to do as we are doing here today, each doing what is right in his own eyes. For you have not yet come to the resting place and the inheritance that the LORD your God is giving you.” Moses addresses Israel east of the Jordan (Deuteronomy 1:1) on the eve of conquest. The people have been worshiping with ad-hoc altars (Exodus 20:24–26; Joshua 8:30–31) and portable rituals suited to nomadic life. The phrase “as we are doing here today” summarizes this provisional, decentralized pattern. Historical Setting: Wilderness Provisionality vs. Land Permanence 1. Mobility: Forty years in camp required flexibility; sacrifices were offered wherever the tabernacle temporarily rested (Numbers 9:15–23). 2. Tribal Dispersion Pending: No permanent borders or Levitical cities yet assigned (Numbers 35). 3. Central Sanctuary Unbuilt: Shiloh, then later Jerusalem (2 Samuel 7:13), lay in the future, so unity of worship awaited a fixed dwelling. Theological Mandate for Centralized Worship • Divine Election of a Place (Deuteronomy 12:5, 11, 14): “the place the LORD your God will choose” anticipates a single altar preventing syncretism. • Covenant Integrity: Multiplicity of local shrines risked Canaanite contamination (Deuteronomy 12:2–4). • Typological Foreshadowing: One chosen sanctuary prefigures the one Mediator, Christ (John 4:21–23; Hebrews 9:11-12). Moral Dimension: Guarding Against Subjectivism The idiom “each doing what is right in his own eyes” mirrors later chaos in Judges 17:6; 21:25. Scripture equates decentralized worship with moral anarchy, illustrating that improper liturgy begets ethical collapse (Romans 1:21–25). Legal Cohesion within Deuteronomy Chapters 12–26 comprise the “Deuteronomic Code.” Verse 12:8 is a thesis statement: remove autonomy, install obedience. Every subsequent stipulation (diet, tithes, festivals, warfare) presumes centralized worship as the covenant’s organizing spine. Archaeological Corroboration • Tel Arad: A Judahite temple (10th–8th c. BC) with twin incense altars, dismantled—likely under Hezekiah’s or Josiah’s centralizing reforms (2 Kings 18:4; 23:8). Evidence confirms tangible obedience to Deuteronomy 12. • Kuntillet ‘Ajrud inscriptions reveal syncretistic Yahweh-Baʿal worship at outlying sites, validating the danger Moses foresaw. • Shiloh Excavations: Burn layer (ca. 1050 BC) squares with 1 Samuel 4–6, showing that once the ark departed, the centralized sanctuary moved, never reverting to random hills. Ancient Near Eastern Contrast Canaanite religion endorsed local “high places” (bamot) for each city-state deity. Deuteronomy counters this with monotheism and mono-locale worship, asserting Yahweh’s supra-territorial sovereignty. Christological Fulfillment and New-Covenant Application Jesus, the incarnate Temple (John 2:19), fulfills centralized worship. Believers now gather “in Spirit and truth” (John 4:24), yet the principle of ordered, God-prescribed worship endures (1 Corinthians 14:40; Hebrews 10:25). Self-styled spirituality remains prohibited. Pastoral and Ethical Implications Today 1. Reject “designer religion”; submit to apostolic teaching (Acts 2:42). 2. Resist moral relativism masquerading as autonomy. 3. Preserve corporate accountability in ecclesial structures. 4. Recognize that obedience precedes inheritance; holiness precedes rest (Hebrews 4:1-11). Answer to Objections • “Temporary command only.” — Moral rationale (guarding against self-rule) transcends the ceremonial. • “Centralization is political, not spiritual.” — The text grounds the command in divine election, not statecraft (Deuteronomy 12:5). • “New Testament freedom nullifies form.” — Freedom perfects, not abolishes, ordered worship (Matthew 5:17; 1 Peter 2:5). Conclusion Deuteronomy 12:8 warns against provisional, self-directed worship and moral relativism. Once settled in the land, Israel must abandon ad-hoc practice, unite under God’s chosen sanctuary, and thereby embody covenant faithfulness—a principle consummated in Christ and still guarding God’s people from doing “whatever is right in our own eyes.” |
    |