Why is the prophecy of Enoch included in Jude but not in the Old Testament? Text of the Prophecy Quoted by Jude “Enoch, the seventh from Adam, also prophesied about them: ‘Behold, the Lord is coming with His myriads of holy ones to execute judgment on everyone…’ ” (Jude 1:14–15). The wording matches 1 Enoch 1:9 in the ancient Ethiopic text and in the Aramaic fragments from Qumran (4Q204), confirming that Jude is drawing on a well-known Jewish source. Canonical Recognition of Jude The early church received Jude as inspired Scripture by the same criteria applied to all New Testament books: apostolic association (Jude is the brother of James and half-brother of Jesus, Matthew 13:55), orthodoxy, and universal reception. By A.D. 170 Jude appears in the Muratorian Fragment, and by the late fourth century every major council (Laodicea c. 363; Hippo 393; Carthage 397) listed it as canonical. Hence anything Jude quotes is ratified, not because the source is canonical, but because the Holy Spirit breathed out Jude (2 Timothy 3:16; 2 Peter 1:21). Who Was Enoch? Genesis 5:24 : “Enoch walked with God, and then he was no more, because God had taken him.” Hebrews 11:5 explains that Enoch “was taken up so that he did not see death.” His seventh-from-Adam placement roots him in the literal, young-earth genealogies that set Earth’s age at only thousands of years, not millions. Enoch’s Prophecy in Ancient Jewish Literature 1 Enoch circulated widely from at least the third century B.C. Dead Sea Scroll caves yielded eleven manuscripts of the work, demonstrating popularity among the Qumran community. Early Jewish writers such as the Book of Jubilees and Sirach echo its themes. The prophecy Jude cites is the book’s opening oracle of final judgment—fitting Jude’s polemic against false teachers. Why the Book of Enoch Was Not Canonical 1 Enoch is pseudepigraphal—claiming Enochic authorship but composed long after the Flood era. It blends genuine patriarchal tradition with later apocalyptic expansions. Because Israel’s prophetic line closed with Malachi (cf. Matthew 11:13), post-exilic writings never attained equal authority. Jesus and the apostles quote or allude to every major Old Testament division but never treat 1 Enoch as Scripture. The first-century Jewish historian Josephus, while listing the Hebrew canon (Contra Apion 1.8), omits it. Authority, therefore, lies not in an ancient book’s antiquity or popularity but in divine inspiration recognized by God’s covenant community. The Holy Spirit’s Inspiration of Jude The Spirit who inspired Genesis also inspired Jude; thus the quotation affirms the prophecy’s truth without elevating the entire pseudepigraphal book. Paul similarly cites pagan poets (Acts 17:28; Titus 1:12) and non-biblical Jewish tradition (2 Timothy 3:8 on Jannes and Jambres). Inspiration guarantees accuracy of the cited words, not wholesale endorsement of the surrounding text. Precedent of Noncanonical Sources in Canonical Text • Joshua 10:13 quotes the “Book of Jashar.” • 1 Chronicles 29:29 references the writings of Samuel, Nathan, and Gad. • Acts 17:28 cites Aratus. Canon therefore may appropriate true statements found outside Scripture. Truth is God’s property wherever it appears; Scripture alone is the infallible rule. Theological Significance of the Quotation 1. Affirmation of Final Judgment: The same Lord who rose bodily (cf. 1 Corinthians 15:3-8) will return with “myriads of holy ones,” echoing Deuteronomy 33:2. 2. Continuity of Revelation: From Enoch to Jude, God’s message of holiness and judgment remains consistent, underscoring Scripture’s unified voice. 3. Validation of Early Prophetic Witness: Enoch’s translation prefigures resurrection, anchoring Jude’s readers in hope while warning the ungodly. Enoch, Judgment, and the Gospel Enoch announces judgment; Jesus provides its escape. John 5:29 promises resurrection “to life” or “to judgment.” Acts 17:31 grounds that certainty in Christ’s resurrection, an event attested by multiple eyewitness groups (1 Corinthians 15:6) and early creedal tradition (vv. 3-4) dated to within five years of the event. Hence Jude’s citation dovetails with the apostolic gospel: judgment is real, rescue is available only in the risen Messiah. Historical and Archaeological Corroboration • Ossuaries inscribed “James, son of Joseph, brother of Jesus” (first-cent. provenance disputed but textually significant) illustrate the family names Jude claims. • The Garden Tomb skull morphology and first-century rolling-stone tombs match gospel burial descriptions, strengthening resurrection claims tied to the same apostolic circle that transmitted Jude. • Flood sediments at the Grand Canyon’s Tapeats Sandstone show rapid, continent-scale deposition, corroborating the Genesis cataclysm Enoch’s generation would have foreseen. Enoch, Resurrection Hope, and Christ Enoch “walked with God, and then he was no more” (Genesis 5:24); Elijah’s translation (2 Kings 2:11) repeats the pattern, both foreshadowing Christ’s ascension (Acts 1:9-11). Jude thus situates believers between initial ascension and imminent return, motivating holy living (Jude 20-21). Practical and Pastoral Applications • Discernment: Measure every source—podcast, book, or vision—against canonical Scripture. • Evangelism: Leverage Jude’s citation to show that prophecy, manuscript evidence, and resurrection converge on one consistent message. • Worship: Marvel that the Lord who judged the ancient world also sent His Son to save it (John 3:17). Summary Jude cites Enoch because the Spirit chose a true, ancient prophecy to indict contemporary scoffers. The quotation’s presence authenticates Jude, not 1 Enoch. Canonical status depends on inspiration, recognized by God’s people, and confirmed by Christ’s resurrection, manuscript reliability, and the seamless unity of Scripture from Genesis to Revelation. |
    |