Why does Genesis 1:31 describe creation as "very good" despite the presence of evil today? Immediate Literary Context Genesis 1 is a chronicle of six sequential, literal, twenty-four-hour creation days (cf. “evening…morning” rhythmic refrain). Day 6 closes with the divine audit: God judges His finished work as “very good,” a superlative absent from the earlier five days, underscoring completion and wholeness. The “very good” verdict therefore applies to the finished, unmarred cosmos—material, biological, moral, and relational. The Temporal Point of Reference: Before the Fall Genesis 1:31 is historically anchored before Genesis 3. No death, pain, disease, thorns, or decay appear in the narrative until Adam’s sin (Genesis 3:17-19; Romans 5:12). Even carnivory is absent: God prescribes a plant-based diet for humans and animals alike (Genesis 1:29-30). The “very good” pronouncement therefore reflects a specific, unfallen moment. Absence of Evil and Death in Original Creation Scripture defines death as an “enemy” (1 Corinthians 15:26), entering through sin (Romans 5:12). God, whose character is holy (Isaiah 6:3) and who cannot tempt with evil (James 1:13), did not weave moral evil into creation’s fabric. The young-earth timeline (≈ 6,000 years) places all fossilized death post-Fall, during the Flood or later, harmonizing geology with the biblical claim of an originally death-free world. Polystrate fossils and global sedimentary megasequences (e.g., Tapeats Sandstone to Redwall Limestone) testify to rapid burial consistent with a catastrophic Flood rather than eons of gradual deposition. The Entrance of Evil: Angelic Rebellion and Human Fall Scripture hints at a prior angelic rebellion (Isaiah 14:12-15; Ezekiel 28:12-17; Revelation 12:4), but evil’s dominion over earth begins with Adam. Granted genuine freedom (Genesis 2:16-17), he transgresses, transferring headship to Satan (Luke 4:6; 2 Corinthians 4:4). The moral order fractures, and entropy invades (Genesis 3:17-19; Romans 8:20). God’s “very good” declaration, therefore, is not negated but historically superseded by a later human act. Consequences on Creation: Curse, Decay, and Death Because Adam was vice-regent over creation (Genesis 1:26-28), his sin reverberated cosmically. Romans 8:19-22 depicts creation “subjected to futility” and “groaning.” Natural disasters, predation, genetic mutations, and disease are downstream effects of the curse, not creative flaws. The law of decay (thermodynamics) presently governs, yet God promises ultimate liberation. Progressive Revelation: Old and New Testaments Affirm Original Goodness • Ecclesiastes 7:29: “God made man upright, but men have gone in search of many schemes.” • Deuteronomy 32:4: “His work is perfect.” • 1 Timothy 4:4: “For every creation of God is good.” These texts endorse Genesis 1:31’s verdict and locate evil’s origin in creaturely rebellion. Christ’s Redemptive Work as Restoration The Second Adam (1 Corinthians 15:45) enters the fallen arena, bears the curse (Galatians 3:13), rises bodily (Luke 24:39), and inaugurates the reversal of Eden’s loss. The resurrection guarantees a refurbished cosmos (Romans 8:23; 2 Peter 3:13). Historical evidence—early creed in 1 Corinthians 15:3-5 (dated AD 30-35), empty tomb attested by hostile witnesses (Matthew 28:11-15), and post-resurrection appearances to 500+ (1 Corinthians 15:6)—anchors this hope. Eschatological Consummation: New Heavens and New Earth Isaiah 65:17, Revelation 21–22, and Acts 3:21 foresee cosmic “restoration.” Carnivory, curse, and death end (Isaiah 11:6-9; Revelation 22:3). The future mirrors and surpasses the “very good” original, confirming Genesis 1:31 as prologue rather than anomaly. Philosophical and Theological Implications 1. Free-will defense: Moral goodness is meaningful only if creatures possess genuine choice. 2. Greater-good theorem: Temporary allowance of evil enables redemptive revelation of divine justice, mercy, and sacrificial love (Romans 5:8). 3. Teleological coherence: Creation, Fall, Redemption, and Consummation form a logically unified narrative. Scientific Corroborations of a Good Original Design • Irreducibly complex systems (bacterial flagellum, ATP synthase) display engineering hallmarks. • Fine-tuned physical constants (strong nuclear force, cosmological constant) permit life. • DNA information density (≈ 215 PB per gram) suggests coded intent. • Living fossils (e.g., Wollemi pine) show stasis rather than evolutionary progress, consistent with created kinds. These elements affirm initial design excellence; current defects reflect subsequent degradation, paralleling the biblical curse model. Archaeological and Manuscript Assurance of the Text Genesis fragments from Qumran (4QGen a, dated 3rd century BC) match the Masoretic consonantal text, confirming textual stability. The Septuagint translation (3rd–2nd century BC) retains “καλὰ λίαν” (“very good”), demonstrating ancient acknowledgment of the superlative. Early patristic citations (e.g., Irenaeus, Against Heresies 4.38.1) quote Genesis 1:31 unaltered. No manuscript evidence attributes evil to God’s creation. Pastoral and Ethical Applications Knowing that evil is alien intruder, not intrinsic design, fortifies assurance in God’s goodness. Suffering invites hope in restoration, not resignation (2 Corinthians 4:16-18). Believers steward creation and oppose moral evil, anticipating renewal. Summary Answer Genesis 1:31 records God’s verdict over an unfallen cosmos: wholly functional, beautiful, and morally pure. Evil entered later through rational creatures’ rebellion, cursing the world but not nullifying the Creator’s original goodness. Scripture, science, history, and eschatological promise together validate the text: creation was “very good,” is now marred, and will be perfectly restored through Christ. |
    |