Why do the disciples mention John the Baptist, Elijah, and ancient prophets in Luke 9:19? Luke 9:19 – Berean Standard Bible “Some say John the Baptist; others say Elijah; and still others, that a prophet of old has arisen.” Immediate Setting Jesus has just fed the five thousand (Luke 9:10-17). As the crowd’s amazement spreads, He asks the disciples, “Who do the crowds say I am?” (v. 18). Their reply in v. 19 records the most common opinions circulating in Galilee. The list reveals the messianic expectations alive in first-century Judaism and shows how Scripture shaped popular speculation. Why John the Baptist? Recent, Powerful, and Now Dead 1. Proximity in Time John’s public ministry (AD 28-30) had ended only months earlier (Luke 3:1-20). His execution by Herod Antipas was fresh news (Matthew 14:1-12). Crowds remembered his bold call to repentance beside the Jordan and naturally connected Jesus’ similar message (Luke 3:7-18; 4:14-21). 2. Resurrection Rumors Herod said, “John I beheaded, but who is this?” (Luke 9:9). Josephus, Antiquities 18.119, confirms Herod’s fear that John’s power might live on. In a culture that expected future resurrection (Daniel 12:2; Isaiah 26:19), some assumed God had vindicated John by raising him. 3. Prophetic Parallels Both men preached in the wilderness, confronted rulers, and baptized multitudes. Like Elijah, John wore camel hair and leather (Mark 1:6; cf. 2 Kings 1:8), further blending these identities in popular thought. Why Elijah? The Scriptural Promise of His Return 1. Malachi’s Last Word Mal 4:5-6 : “Behold, I will send you Elijah the prophet before the coming of the great and awesome day of the LORD.” For four centuries no canonical prophet had arisen. Jews therefore awaited Elijah as Messiah’s forerunner (Sirach 48:10; 1 Enoch 90:31). 2. Ascension Without Death Elijah never died but was taken to heaven alive (2 Kings 2:11). This unique departure fed expectation that he could reappear bodily. 3. Role of Miracle Worker Elijah multiplied flour and oil, raised a widow’s son, and called down fire (1 Kings 17–18). Jesus’ similar miracles (e.g., raising Jairus’s daughter, multiplying bread) matched Elijah-typology, prompting people to see Him as that very prophet. “One of the Ancient Prophets Has Arisen”: The Broader Hope 1. Deuteronomy’s “Prophet Like Moses” Deut 18:15-18 promised a prophet whom Israel must hear. While the Dead Sea Scrolls (4QTest; 11QMelch) show Qumran linking this figure to the eschaton, the populace applied the title loosely to any revered prophet—perhaps Moses, Jeremiah, or Isaiah—returning to guide Israel. 2. Second Temple Literature 2 Macc 2:4-8 recounts Jeremiah hiding the ark and promising to return before the end; 2 Baruch 40:1-3 speaks of the righteous dead appearing again. Such texts fostered the idea of ancient prophets being raised in the last days. 3. Resurrection in Jewish Thought Pharisaic doctrine affirmed bodily resurrection (Acts 23:8); inscriptions at first-century Ossuary sites around Jerusalem echo hope in life after death. Thus “arisen” (ἀνέστη) made perfect sense to first-century ears. Cultural and Political Factors Intensifying Speculation 1. Roman Oppression & Messianic Fervor Heavy taxation, incompetence of Herodian rulers, and the Roman presence magnified longing for divine intervention. 2. Prophetic Silence Broken After centuries without a canonical prophet, John’s and Jesus’ ministries signaled, to many, the rekindling of the prophetic era. 3. Echoes of Moses and Elijah on Mount Carmel & Sinai Jesus taught on mountains, calmed seas, and fed multitudes in wilderness settings—imagery loaded with Exodus and Elijah parallels. Archaeological Corroboration • Herod Antipas’s palace at Machaerus, where John was beheaded, has been excavated (Ehud Netzer, 1978-84), confirming Josephus’s description. • Bethsaida, the backdrop for the feeding of the five thousand (Luke 9:10), has yielded first-century fishing implements and residential structures, affirming the Gospel’s geographic accuracy. • A first-century “John son of Haggo” bathing stone found near Qasr el-Yahud matches ritual immersion practices, illustrating the cultural milieu of baptizing prophets. Theological Purpose in Luke’s Narrative Luke includes the public’s confusion to set up Peter’s Spirit-revealed confession, “You are the Christ of God” (Luke 9:20). The contrast between popular conjecture and apostolic certainty highlights the insufficiency of human speculation versus divine revelation. Practical Implications 1. Fulfillment Recognized: Elijah did come—in John’s spirit and power (Luke 1:17)—and yet the crowd still missed Jesus’ full identity. 2. Resurrection Anticipated: Their willingness to believe prophets could rise again underscores the plausibility of Christ’s own resurrection, historically verified (1 Corinthians 15:3-8). 3. Personal Response: As then, public opinion today offers many inadequate portraits of Jesus. The decisive issue remains Peter’s confession and each person’s call to acknowledge Jesus as Lord and risen Savior. Summary The disciples reported John, Elijah, and the ancient prophets because Scripture, recent events, and fervent eschatological hope made those figures the most plausible explanations for Jesus’ unprecedented authority. Luke records these options to contrast them with the Spirit-given truth that Jesus is not merely another prophet returned but the long-promised, risen Messiah—the only Name by which we must be saved (Acts 4:12). |
    |