How can a loving God command the destruction of an entire city in Joshua 6:21? Text and Context of Joshua 6:21 “Then they devoted to destruction all that was in the city, both men and women, young and old, oxen, sheep, and donkeys, with the edge of the sword.” The verse describes Israel’s first military action after crossing the Jordan. It concludes a divinely directed seven-day siege in which the walls of Jericho collapsed miraculously (Joshua 6:20). Historical and Archaeological Setting of Jericho Excavations at Tell es-Sultan—identified as Jericho—show a collapsed mud-brick wall at the base of a still-standing stone revetment, the only Late Bronze city in Canaan where such outward-tumbled debris exists. Stratified jars filled with charred grain, buried beneath that rubble, attest a short siege ending in spring (the time of barley harvest; Joshua 3:15) and a sudden fiery destruction (Joshua 6:24). Radiocarbon analysis of the grain clusters the event c. 1400 BC—consistent with a conservative Exodus date of 1446 BC and forty years of wilderness wandering. These findings confirm Scripture’s claim that Jericho fell abruptly, was burned, and was not looted (the grain was left). The archaeological record therefore grounds the biblical account in verifiable history. Divine Holiness and Canaanite Wickedness Yahweh’s holiness necessitates judging persistent evil. Leviticus 18 and Deuteronomy 18 catalog Canaanite practices—child sacrifice, ritual prostitution, necromancy—that had reached intolerable depths. Genesis 15:16 reveals God withheld judgment for four centuries until “the iniquity of the Amorites” was complete, demonstrating patience before executing justice. Gradual Warnings and Probation During Israel’s wilderness travel, neighboring peoples witnessed the Red Sea crossing, manna, and the defeat of Og and Sihon. Rahab testifies, “We heard how the LORD dried up the waters of the Red Sea… our hearts melted” (Joshua 2:10-11). Jericho enjoyed at least forty years of foreknowledge and seven additional days of trumpeted procession around its walls—ample opportunity to surrender or evacuate under a recognized Ancient Near-Eastern rules-of-engagement concept called šulmu (peace offer). Jericho as Military Stronghold, Not Innocent Village Jericho was a royal fortress guarding strategic entry to the central hill country. Populations inside during a siege were overwhelmingly combatants and conscripted support. Archaeology indicates a walled citadel, not a sprawling civilian metropolis. Comparable Hittite and Egyptian garrison-towns housed soldiers’ families, meaning non-combatants were directly invested in warfare logistics. The Principle of Ḥerem (“Devoted to Destruction”) Ḥerem signified something placed wholly under divine jurisdiction. In Jericho, every living thing and all precious metal were set apart for God (Joshua 6:17-19). The action was theological, not ethnic, preventing Israel from acquiring plunder and thus averting syncretism with Canaanite religion. Later texts show that Ḥerem judgments were rare, covenant-specific, geographically limited, and reversible when repentance occurred (cf. Nineveh in Jonah 3). Corporate Judgment and Federal Headship Scripture views humanity corporately: Adam’s sin impacts descendants (Romans 5:12-19); Christ’s righteousness benefits all who believe. Likewise, Canaanite society—familial, tribal, cultic—was judged as a unit because its evil was communal. Infants, though individually innocent, belonged to a culture under divine condemnation. God, who sovereignly gives life, retains the right to recall it (Job 1:21) and can extend eternal mercy to children beyond earthly death. Miracle and Mercy: Rahab as Case Study Rahab—a Canaanite, cult prostitute, and citizen of Jericho—escaped judgment through faith, becoming ancestress of Messiah (Matthew 1:5). Her rescue demonstrates that God’s judgment is never indiscriminate; repentance yields salvation, even amid Ḥerem. Typology and Redemptive Purposes Jericho foreshadows ultimate eschatological judgment. Revelation 18 parallels Jericho’s fall, portraying a wicked world system crushed so a redeemed creation can emerge. The scarlet cord (Joshua 2:18) anticipates Christ’s atoning blood safeguarding believers from wrath (Hebrews 9:22). Philosophical Considerations: God’s Prerogative over Life Because God is Creator (Genesis 1:1; Colossians 1:16-17), He holds absolute authority over life and death. His actions cannot be measured by autonomous human standards; instead, human moral intuition derives from His nature. If one objects to Jericho while affirming elective abortion or total-war bombings, the complaint is selective. Consistent moral reasoning begins with the objective Lawgiver. Answering the “Genocide” Accusation Genocide targets an ethnic group for annihilation. Jericho’s destruction was judicial, conditional, and non-racial. Later, repentant Canaanites (e.g., Gibeonites) were spared (Joshua 9). Foreigners who embraced Israel’s God participated fully in covenant life (Numbers 15:15-16). The issue was allegiance, not lineage. Psychological and Behavioral Insights on Justice and Moral Law Cross-cultural studies reveal an innate human cry for justice. When heinous crimes go unpunished, societies fracture. Scripture’s portrayal of decisive judgment aligns with observed psychological needs for moral resolution, validating the Bible’s depiction of a God who actively rights wrongs. Miracles, Historical Veracity, and Intelligent Design The supernatural collapse of Jericho’s walls involved timing (the last trumpet-blast) and directionality (outward), contradicting earthquake patterns yet leaving Rahab’s adjoining section intact (Joshua 2:15; 6:22-23). Such targeted intervention parallels modern medically documented healings where malignant tumors vanish following prayer within minutes—events peer-reviewed by physicians who exclude spontaneous remission. Both kinds of miracles affirm divine sovereignty and invite trust in Scriptural revelation. Christological Fulfillment and the Loving Purpose of Judgment The same God who judged Jericho later bore judgment Himself on the cross. Isaiah 53:6 declares, “The LORD has laid on Him the iniquity of us all.” Divine love is proved, not disproved, by Jericho: the God who hates sin enough to judge it also loves sinners enough to pay their penalty. Practical Implications for Believers and Skeptics For believers, Jericho instills sobriety about sin, urgency in evangelism, and confidence in God’s promises. For skeptics, the historical evidence of Jericho’s fall, combined with the resurrected Christ’s empty tomb, challenges the assumption that biblical miracles are myth. If God can raise Jesus bodily—a fact affirmed by the majority of critical scholars through minimal facts methodology—then commanding judgment at Jericho is neither illogical nor inconsistent with love, for the risen Lord invites every person to escape future judgment by trusting in Him today (John 3:16-18). |
    |