Who was Diotrephes in the Bible? Background and Context Diotrephes appears in the New Testament in the short letter of 3 John. This epistle, addressed to a believer named Gaius, provides insight into the challenges faced by the early Christian community. While the letter is short, it contains strong statements about the behaviors and attitudes of key individuals—one of whom is Diotrephes. The text of 3 John is one of the shortest writings in the New Testament, yet its historical and spiritual significance is remarkable. Diotrephes is mentioned only in this passage, where the Apostle John highlights his problematic demeanor and actions toward fellow believers. Scriptural References The primary reference to Diotrephes is found in 3 John 1:9–10. The Apostle John writes: “I wrote to the church, but Diotrephes, who loves to be first, will not accept our instruction. So if I come, I will call attention to what he is doing, spreading malicious nonsense about us. Not satisfied with that, he refuses to welcome the brothers and forbids those who want to do so, and expels them from the church.” (3 John 1:9–10) This description provides nearly all we know of Diotrephes, but it also raises several important considerations about early church authority and unity. Name and Possible Implications The name “Diotrephes” (Greek: Διοτρέφης) can be interpreted as “nourished by Zeus” or “nourished by Jupiter.” Such a name suggests possible pagan origins or, at the least, a Greek cultural background. While this does not inherently imply Diotrephes’s loyalty to pagan beliefs, the culturally Greek name indicates that converts to Christianity came from many different backgrounds in the first-century church. Role and Influence in the Early Church 1. Likely a Local Church Leader Since Diotrephes could command enough authority to expel people from fellowship, he held a position of some influence—perhaps as an elder, overseer, or a host of the local assembly. In the early church, gatherings often took place in homes, meaning that homeowners or sponsors wielded considerable practical and financial authority. 2. Refusal to Welcome Fellow Workers The passage in 3 John suggests that Diotrephes actively opposed the traveling ministers or missionaries whom John endorsed. Hospitality was critical to the spread of the gospel, and those who refused it — as Diotrephes did — harmed the unity and outreach efforts of the early Christian communities. 3. Challenging the Apostle John’s Authority John specifically mentions that Diotrephes “will not accept our instruction” (3 John 1:9). In the early church, apostolic authority was foundational for doctrine and moral guidance. The fact that Diotrephes rejected it implies a serious division in the church, as well as a self-exalting attitude that worked against the apostolic teaching. Key Characteristics of Diotrephes 1. Love of Preeminence John writes that Diotrephes “loves to be first.” This phrase indicates pride or a desire for control within the church—traits that were (and are) in direct opposition to the servant leadership modeled and taught by Jesus (cf. Mark 10:43–44). 2. Spreading Malicious Talk Diotrephes is accused of spreading “malicious nonsense” about John and his associates (3 John 1:10). Such behavior undermined unity and disrupted the fellowship. In an environment where hospitality and trust were foundational, slander was a serious hindrance to ministry. 3. Refusal to Show Hospitality Hospitality held significant importance in the New Testament era, both culturally and spiritually. Denying hospitality to traveling teachers—endorsed by John himself—amounted to thwarting the gospel work. Diotrephes’s refusal to welcome the brethren stands in direct opposition to the commendation John gives to Gaius for his generous hospitality earlier in 3 John (see 3 John 1:5–8). 4. Forbidding Others In addition to his own lack of hospitality, Diotrephes is said to stop others from showing kindness to the visiting brothers, even expelling them from the church if they did so (3 John 1:10). This misuse of power disrupted fellowship and sowed fear among believers who wished to obey the apostolic command to welcome faithful workers. Historical and Cultural Context The letter of 3 John provides a window into the local administration and varied leadership styles of the early believers. Unlike modern denominational structures, the early house churches often depended on influential figures who hosted or supervisied gatherings. It was possible for someone like Diotrephes, who had become prominent in one such local assembly, to misuse that influence. While we do not have external historical accounts or patristic writings elaborating on Diotrephes’s later actions, the biblical text offers ample evidence of his controlling attitude. His example serves as a cautionary tale: even in the presence of apostolic teaching, personal ambition and pride can disrupt unity. The Apostle John’s Response 1. Calling Attention to the Issue John does not allow Diotrephes’s behavior to go unchallenged. He clearly states, “So if I come, I will call attention to what he is doing…” (3 John 1:10). This direct confrontation underscores a biblical principle of addressing issues that hinder the church. 2. Invocation of Apostolic Authority Since John was an apostle, his authority came from Christ (cf. Luke 6:13; John 20:21). By challenging John, Diotrephes was opposing more than just a fellow believer—he was challenging apostolic instruction given for the edification and protection of the church. 3. Contrast with Commendable Behavior Throughout 3 John, one can observe an implicit contrast between Gaius, who is praised for walking in truth and showing hospitality, and Diotrephes, who is criticized for opposing such virtues. This dualism highlights how believers can choose either to uphold or hinder the gospel work. Significance for Believers Today 1. Warning Against Pride The account of Diotrephes reminds believers of the spiritual dangers of pride and seeking to be “first.” True Christian leadership, as exemplified by Jesus Himself, is based on humility and servanthood. 2. Responsibility to Uphold Truth By refusing the instructions of John, Diotrephes placed personal interests above scriptural truth. In any era, embracing the instruction of Scripture and the foundational truths passed down from the apostles remains crucial for the health of the church. 3. Consequences of Divisive Actions Diotrephes’s behavior showcased how one individual’s divisive actions can hinder ministry, harm relationships, and disrupt congregational cohesion. This underscores the importance of discerning leadership and safeguarding unity in the community of believers. 4. Encouragement to Practice Hospitality The contrast between Diotrephes and those who welcomed brothers in Christ emphasizes the biblical mandate to show hospitality (Romans 12:13; Hebrews 13:2). Openness to believers and commitment to gospel proclamation remain central themes for Christian communities today. Conclusion Diotrephes stands as a striking example of pride and opposition to apostolic authority in the early Christian church. Mentioned only in 3 John, he nevertheless provides vital lessons about leadership, hospitality, and humility. His refusal to receive servants of the gospel and his attempts to hinder others from doing so underscores how personal ambition can impede the work of God’s kingdom. By studying Diotrephes’s actions and the Apostle John’s response, believers gain insights into preserving spiritual unity, upholding biblical teaching, and practicing genuine love. Though centuries have passed, the biblical caution presented through Diotrephes’s example remains timely and instructive, underscoring the need for humility, submission to godly counsel, and devotion to the truth of Scripture. |
    |