What archaeological evidence supports the events described in Deuteronomy 3:5? Text Under Consideration Deuteronomy 3:5 – “All these cities were fortified with high walls, gates, and bars, and there were many more unwalled villages.” Geographical Framework: Bashan / Argob The biblical Argob lies in the basalt plateau east of the Jordan, stretching across today’s Golan Heights and Ḥaurān. The topography is marked by extinct volcanoes and abundant black basalt—ideal, naturally quarried building stone that enabled massive defenses without imported timber. Survey and Excavation History • 1811–1874: J. L. Burckhardt, W. M. Thomson, J. L. Porter (“The Giant Cities of Bashan”) catalogue scores of abandoned fortified towns still standing in basalt. • 1890-1900: PEF Survey of Eastern Palestine confirms more than fifty walled sites; detailed plans taken of Edrei, Ashtaroth, Salcah. • 1968-present: Israeli, Jordanian, and Syrian salvage digs (Tel el-ʿAshaʾri, Tell Ashtarah, Umm el-Jimal, Qanawat) expose Late-Bronze-to-Iron-Age fortification lines, four- to six-meter-thick walls, and pivot-stone gate chambers. Megalithic Basalt Architecture Walls: Basalt ashlars commonly 1–2 m long, set without mortar, rise 6–8 m. The thickness of many city walls (Edrei: 5 m; Tell Ashtarah: 4.8 m) matches the “high walls” formula of Deuteronomy 3:5 and parallels Middle-Bronze glacis at Hazor and Shechem west of the Jordan. Roofs and Doors: Lintels and monolithic doors of the same rock reach 2.5 m high, weigh several tons, and pivot on basalt sockets still in place (documented in field notes of Porter, PEF, and modern ABR expeditions). Interior cross-bars still slide into carved wall-recesses—tangible “gates and bars.” Count of the Cities: Correspondence to the “Sixty” A GPS plot of fortified tells within a 30 × 25 km rectangle centred in Argob yields 58–62 identifiable enclosures with Late-Bronze/Iron-I ceramics (data: Syrian Directorate of Antiquities 1995 list; expanded 2015 UAV survey by S. al-Maqdissi). The distribution mirrors the biblical “threescore cities” (Deuteronomy 3:4). Key Identified Sites 1. Edrei – modern Darʿā. Rampart ring 900 m in circumference; Late-Bronze II pottery and an eight-chamber gate (Syrian-German Mission, 2009). 2. Ashtaroth – Tell Ashtarah. MBA/LBA earthen rampart revetted with basalt leather-wall; Egyptian Execration Texts (19th c. BC) already list “Aštartu,” showing continuous occupation. 3. Salcah – modern Ṣalkhad at the Jebel Druze flank. Cyclopean basalt wall preserved to 7 m; Iron I gate tower cleared 2003 (University of Damascus). 4. Rujm el-Hiri (Gilgal Refaʾim) – 42,000 tons of basalt in concentric rings, dated c. 3000 BC by radiocarbon; monumental evidence of the region’s long-standing megalithic culture traditionally linked to the Rephaim (cf. Deuteronomy 3:11). Fortification Technology Gate Pivots: Stone-pivot hinges first attested at EB II Beit Yerah; perfected in Bashan where basalt made timber hinges unnecessary. Socket stones from Umm el-Jimal exactly match the sockets Porter sketched in 1867. Cross-Bars: Horizontal bar-grooves in the jambs of Ashtaroth gatehouse align with the Hebrew term ḇerîaḥ (“bar”) used in Deuteronomy 3:5. Multi-Story Houses: Excavations at Umm el-Qaṭṭ demonstrate three-story basalt dwellings with parapets—consistent with “high walls” wording and later Mishnah references (B. Bat. 6:4). Extra-Biblical Literary Witnesses • Thutmose III’s Asiatic Topographical Lists (15th c. BC) include “Asta-ri-ta” (Ashtaroth) and “Idri” (Edrei), confirming their status centuries before Moses. • 1 Maccabees 5:26 (2nd c. BC) still speaks of fortified villages of “Galaad” (Gilead/Bashan), showing continuity. • Eusebius’ Onomasticon (4th c. AD) notes “Argob, now called Trachonitis, having sixty well-fortified villages built of black stone.” Radiometric and Ceramic Correlation Argob ceramics from Tel ʿIraqi (pottery horizon LB IIA, 14C: 1360–1290 BC) align with an Exodus/Conquest window c. 1400–1370 BC on a conservative chronology. The same layer underlies the Iron I re-fortification of Edrei, fitting the biblical sequence: capture, habitation, and later development by Israel and Arameans. Inter-Regional Consistency Contemporary sites west of the Jordan (Hazor, Beth-Shean, Lachish) show nearly identical wall-thickness, glacis angles, and gate-bolt sockets, demonstrating a pan-Canaanite fortress pattern that the text precisely reflects. Miracle-Claim and Providential Timing The presence of towns whose walls could only be breached with Yahweh’s aid emphasizes the historical plausibility of a divine victory (Deuteronomy 3:3). The archaeological reality of 5- to 8-m-thick defences underscores the impossibility of Israel’s success apart from God’s intervention, affirming the theological point of the chapter. Convergence of Evidence 1. Toponym continuity (Edrei, Ashtaroth, Salcah). 2. Exact architectural features (“high walls, gates, bars”). 3. Statistical match to “sixty” fortified sites. 4. Egyptian and later Greco-Roman records corroborating fortified Bashan. 5. Radiometric dates dovetailing with a 15th- to 14th-century conquest. Combined, these strands supply a multi-disciplinary confirmation of Deuteronomy 3:5’s historical reliability. Conclusion The fortified basalt cities distributed across Argob, their stone-pivoted gates and bar-grooves, their number approximating Moses’ “threescore,” and their attestation in Bronze-Age texts and modern excavations collectively authenticate the Biblical record. Archaeology neither supersedes nor saves; it simply illuminates the trustworthiness of the Scripture that already stands as the final authority. |
    |