Does Joab's action obey God's commands?
How does Joab's action reflect obedience to God's commands in Scripture?

Setting the Scene in 1 Chronicles 21

1 Chronicles 21:1–4 records David ordering a census, ignoring Joab’s warning that “the LORD multiply His people a hundredfold” (v. 3).

• Verse 6 notes Joab’s refusal to number Levi and Benjamin because “the king’s command was detestable to him.”


What God Had Said about Numbering Israel

Exodus 30:11-16 – A census was permissible only if each man paid a ransom to avert plague.

Numbers 1:1-3 – God-authorized censuses were conducted specifically to prepare for war.

Numbers 1:47-50 – “The Levites, however, were not numbered… for the LORD had told Moses: ‘Do not count the tribe of Levi.’”

• The pattern: any numbering had to be commanded by God, carried out His way, and exclude Levi. David’s census met none of these conditions.


Joab’s Immediate Response: A Heart Sensitive to God

• He protested: “Why should my lord require this? Why should he bring guilt on Israel?” (1 Chronicles 21:3).

• Though under royal command, Joab’s conscience was tethered first to divine command.

Proverbs 28:14 – “Blessed is the man who always fears the LORD, but he who hardens his heart falls into trouble.” Joab feared the LORD enough to resist fully complying.


Leaving Levi Out: Direct Alignment with God’s Command

• Joab’s omission of Levi mirrors Numbers 1:49 – God Himself had excluded Levi from military counts.

• By obeying this earlier, explicit word, Joab honored Scripture over David’s order.

• His selective obedience reveals he knew God’s law and applied it even under pressure.


Why Benjamin Was Spared: Respect for God’s Sacred Places

• Benjamin’s territory held Jerusalem and the tabernacle-site at Gibeon (1 Chronicles 16:39).

Deuteronomy 12:5 warns that the chosen worship site is to be revered. Joab likely viewed numbering Benjamin—as host tribe for the sanctuary—as an added profanation.

• By withholding Benjamin, he minimized desecration of holy ground.


Partial Obedience vs. Complete Obedience

• Joab obeyed God where he clearly could (Levi and Benjamin) yet still completed most of the census.

• His action is a reminder of Romans 14:23 – “everything that is not of faith is sin.” He obeyed to the extent of his faith, revealing both courage and limitation.

• The final plague (1 Chronicles 21:14) shows that partial obedience cannot cancel disobedience at the top. Still, God noted Joab’s reverence in the inspired record.


Lessons for Us Today

• Know Scripture well enough to recognize when human directives oppose God’s word.

• Even under authority, we remain personally accountable to obey God first (Acts 5:29).

• Small acts of fidelity—like Joab’s refusal to number certain tribes—still matter to God and are recorded for our instruction (Romans 15:4).

Why did Joab exclude Levi and Benjamin from the census in 1 Chronicles 21:6?
Top of Page
Top of Page