Is it lawful for us to pay taxes to Caesar or not? Text and Immediate Context “Is it lawful for us to pay taxes to Caesar or not?” (Luke 20:22). The query arises during Passion Week when the chief priests and scribes, joined by Herodians (parallel, Mark 12:13), attempt to ensnare Jesus between Roman authority and Jewish nationalism. The wider unit, Luke 20:20-26, is framed by two parables (vv 9-19; vv 27-40) that expose religious hypocrisy and affirm Jesus’ Messianic authority. Historical Background: Roman Taxation in Judea After A.D. 6 Judea became an imperial province; Rome imposed the κῆνσος (poll/tribute tax) payable by every adult male with a silver denarius bearing Tiberius’ image and legend, “TI CAESAR DIVI AVG F AVGVSTVS”—“Tiberius Caesar, son of the divine Augustus.” Archaeological finds of these denarii (e.g., Hoard, Beth-Shean, Israel Museum inv. 76-100) corroborate Luke’s setting. Josephus notes fierce Jewish objection to such tribute (Ant. 18.1.1), and the Zealot slogan “No king but Yahweh” echoed Exodus 20:3. The Trap Saying “yes” would alienate nationalists; saying “no” would invite charges of sedition (cf. Luke 23:2). Their objective: “to seize on His words, so as to deliver Him to the rule and authority of the governor” (Luke 20:20). Jesus’ Counter-Question and Verdict He requests “a denarius,” exposing their ready use of the coin they deemed idolatrous. “Whose image and inscription are on it?” They said, “Caesar’s.” He said to them, “Then render to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s, and to God the things that are God’s” (Luke 20:24-25). Exegetical Notes 1. “Render” (ἀπόδοτε) conveys repayment of a rightful debt. 2. Implicit contrast: coins bear Caesar’s εἰκών (image); humanity bears God’s (Genesis 1:27). 3. Double obligation: civil (Romans 13:1-7) and divine (Deuteronomy 6:4-5). Old Testament Foundations • Tribute precedents: Joseph’s Pharaoh tax (Genesis 47:24). • Jeremiah urges submission to Babylon (Jeremiah 29:7). • Proverbs 8:15—“By Me kings reign.” New Testament Development • Romans 13:1-7, civil authority “God’s servant for your good.” • 1 Peter 2:13-17: honor the emperor, fear God. • Acts 5:29 sets the hierarchy: obey God rather than men when commands conflict. Christological Dimension Jesus, the rightful Davidic King (Luke 1:32-33), willingly affirms limited civic duty while preserving supreme allegiance to God. His crucifixion under Roman authority (“INRI” titulus) demonstrates submission leading to atonement (Philippians 2:8). Resurrection validated His authority over every earthly power (Matthew 28:18). Ethical and Practical Application 1. Pay taxes with integrity; cheating civil revenue is theft (Ephesians 4:28). 2. Engage government prayerfully (1 Timothy 2:1-2). 3. When state mandates contradict Scripture (e.g., Acts 4:18-20), practice respectful civil disobedience. 4. Steward God’s image: life, body, talents, evangelism (Matthew 28:19-20). Archaeological Corroboration • The Pilate Stone (Caesarea, 1961) confirms prefecture context. • Temple-tax Tyrian shekels uncovered near Jerusalem clarify coin circulation alongside Roman denarii. • First-century inscription from Paphlagonia lists an imperial tax decree matching Luke’s terminology. Philosophical Reflection Human governance exhibits intelligible order—a hallmark of design. Objective moral duty to pay “what is owed” (Romans 13:7) presupposes a transcendent moral Lawgiver, aligning with the moral argument for God’s existence. Conclusion Yes, Christians may and must pay Caesar what bears his image, yet reserve worship, ultimate loyalty, and their very selves—stamped with God’s image—for the Creator and Redeemer. Rightly ordered allegiance safeguards witness, fulfills righteousness, and glorifies God in a watching world. |
    |