Joshua 17:13: Israel's obedience?
How does Joshua 17:13 reflect Israel's obedience to God's commands?

Setting the Verse in Context

Joshua 17:13: ‘When the Israelites grew stronger, they imposed forced labor on the Canaanites, but they did not drive them out completely.’”

• This statement comes after land allotments are described for Ephraim and Manasseh (Joshua 16–17).

• The Lord had already promised victory and land (Joshua 1:2-6). Israel now possesses strength and numbers to carry out God’s directives.


God’s Explicit Command

Exodus 23:31-33; Deuteronomy 7:1-2; 20:16-18 – “You must drive them out completely… show them no favor.”

Joshua 11:15 – “Joshua left nothing undone of all that the LORD had commanded Moses.”

• The command was crystal-clear: eliminate Canaanite influence to protect covenant purity and worship.


What Israel Actually Did

• Positive note: “When the Israelites grew stronger…” – the Lord’s promise of empowerment is fulfilled.

• Partial obedience:

– They “imposed forced labor” (tribute, taxes, corvée labor).

– They “did not drive them out completely.”

• Parallel situations: Joshua 16:10; Judges 1:27-35 record the same pattern among other tribes.


Why Partial Obedience Matters

• God views incomplete obedience as disobedience (1 Samuel 15:22-23).

• Remaining Canaanites became a snare: Judges 2:1-3; 3:5-6 shows intermarriage, idolatry, eventual oppression.

• Israel’s choice reveals a preference for economic gain (cheap labor) over covenant loyalty.


Key Observations about Obedience in Joshua 17:13

• Demonstrated strength – Israel had everything needed to obey fully.

• Selective compliance – they honored the easier part of God’s command (rule over the land) while rejecting the harder part (complete expulsion of idolatry).

• Foreshadowing – sets up the spiritual roller-coaster of Judges, highlighting the cost of compromise.


Lessons Drawn from the Verse

• Obedience is all-or-nothing; partial measures carry unseen consequences.

• Material benefit must never outrank spiritual fidelity.

• God’s instructions remain authoritative even after apparent success; strength is granted to facilitate obedience, not excuse shortcuts.

Joshua 17:13 shows a people who possessed power to fulfill God’s word yet settled for manageable control instead of wholehearted obedience—a sober reminder that divine commands deserve complete, unhesitating compliance.

Why did Israel choose forced labor over driving out the Canaanites completely?
Top of Page
Top of Page