Matthew 18:19 vs. unanswered prayers?
How does Matthew 18:19 align with unanswered prayers in a believer's life?

Matthew 18:19

“Again, I tell you truly that if two of you on the earth agree about any matter that you ask for, it will be done for you by My Father in heaven.”


Immediate Literary Setting

Matthew 18:15-20 addresses church discipline. The “agreement” (Greek symphōnēsōsin) follows the language of “binding and loosing” (v.18), showing Christ’s promise of heavenly ratification when His people seek His will in restoring a sinning brother. The focus is corporate, judicial, and missional, not a blanket guarantee of personal requests.


Broader Canonical Harmony

Scripture never contradicts itself (Psalm 119:160). Dozens of passages qualify prayer promises:

1 John 5:14-15—requests “according to His will.”

John 15:7—“If you remain in Me and My words remain in you.”

James 4:3—wrong motives nullify petitions.

Psalm 66:18—cherished sin blocks prayer.

Matthew 18:19 must be read through these lenses.


Necessary Conditions for Answered Corporate Prayer

a) Agreement in Spirit and Truth

The term symphōnia implies more than verbal concurrence; it demands unity produced by the Spirit (Ephesians 4:3). Two quarrelsome believers mouthing identical words lack the harmony Jesus commends (1 Peter 3:7).

b) Alignment with God’s Revealed Will

Prayer is an act of delegated authority. As Chrysostom noted (Homilies on Matthew 60), the promise is “when those agreeing are seeking the things that please God.” Hence church petitions for unbiblical outcomes—e.g., affirming sin—have no divine endorsement.

c) Covenant Obedience and Holiness

Isaiah 59:1-2 ties unanswered prayer to unconfessed sin. In context, Matthew 18 requires repentance and reconciliation before prayer (see vv.15-17; cf. Mark 11:25).

d) Faith, Perseverance, and Divine Timing

Mark 11:24 links believing prayer with God’s commitment to act, yet Luke 18:1-8 exhorts persistent asking. God’s “delay” often perfects faith (Romans 5:3-5).


Why Earnest, Agreed-Upon Prayers May Seem Unanswered

a) Sovereign Redirection Toward a Greater Good

Paul pleaded thrice for his thorn; Christ answered with sustaining grace, not removal (2 Corinthians 12:7-10). The Father sometimes says “no” or “wait” to grant superior blessings (Romans 8:28).

b) Sanctification Through Unmet Longings

Hebrews 12:6 links discipline with love. Unanswered prayer can expose idolatry and redirect affections to God Himself (Psalm 73:25-26).

c) Spiritual Warfare and Providential Delay

Daniel’s 21-day wait (Daniel 10:12-14) reveals angelic conflict affecting earthly answers. Believers today still wrestle “against spiritual forces” (Ephesians 6:12).

d) Corporate Disorder

Disunity nullifies collective petitions (1 Corinthians 1:10; 11:18-30). Matthew 18’s promise presumes a reconciled assembly.


Biblical Illustrations

• Gethsemane (Matthew 26:39)—The perfect Son submits His request to the Father’s will, modeling obedient relinquishment.

• Early Church (Acts 12)—The church prays; Peter is delivered while James is executed. Divine sovereignty governs differential outcomes within the same praying body.

• George Müller (1805-1898)—Over 50,000 recorded answers to prayer affirm God’s faithfulness; yet Müller waited decades for several conversions, underscoring divine pacing.


Practical Guidance for Believers Facing Silence

a) Examine the Heart (Psalm 139:23-24).

b) Pursue Reconciliation (Matthew 5:23-24).

c) Saturate Requests with Scripture; pray God’s promises back to Him (Nehemiah 1:8-9).

d) Enlist Spirit-led Agreement—small groups, elders, family (Acts 4:23-31).

e) Accept God’s Sovereign Outcome with Worship (Habakkuk 3:17-19).


Pastoral Encouragement

Unanswered prayer is not unheard prayer (1 Peter 3:12). The resurrection of Christ guarantees that every petition offered through Him reaches the Father (Hebrews 7:25). In eternity, believers will discern how every delayed or denied request served the “praise of His glorious grace” (Ephesians 1:6).


Conclusion

Matthew 18:19 is a robust promise linked to corporate harmony, covenant obedience, and God’s will. Apparent non-responses do not negate Christ’s words; they invite deeper conformity to His purposes, sustained by the assurance that the Father who raised Jesus is both able and wise to grant what most magnifies His glory and our eternal good.

Does Matthew 18:19 guarantee that God will grant any request made by two believers?
Top of Page
Top of Page