How does Matthew 7:5 relate to the theme of hypocrisy in the Bible? Canonical Context within the Sermon on the Mount Matthew 7:5 stands in a triad (vv. 1-5) warning against censorious judgment. Verses 3-4 present the comedic hyperbole of a δοκός (beam) versus a κάρφος (speck). Verse 5 drives home the charge of hypocrisy: the critic ignores a massive moral failure while nit-picking minor flaws in others. The verse therefore exposes self-righteous moral evaluation apart from self-examination. Old Testament Foundations of Anti-Hypocrisy 1. Isaiah 29:13—“This people draw near with their mouths… yet their hearts are far from Me.” 2. Psalm 51:6—“Surely You desire truth in the inmost being.” 3. Amos 5:21-24—worship divorced from justice is loathsome to God. From Cain’s unacceptable sacrifice (Genesis 4) to Saul’s partial obedience (1 Samuel 15), the Hebrew Scriptures insist that God weighs the heart, forbidding mere externalism. Intertestamental and Second Temple Background The Dead Sea Scrolls (e.g., 1QS, the Community Rule) decry “men of the lie” who honor God with words while walking in darkness. First-century Judaism thus already wrestled with religious pretense, sharpening the relevance of Jesus’ rebuke. New Testament Development of the Theme • Matthew 23:13-28: Seven “woes” against scribes and Pharisees for masking inner decay. • Luke 6:42, echoing Matthew 7:5, confirms Lukan independence yet thematic unity. • Romans 2:1-24: Paul indicts moralists who condemn others while practicing the same sins. • Galatians 2:11-14: Peter’s withdrawal from Gentiles is called “hypocrisy.” • James 1:22-27; 3:17: genuine religion is “without hypocrisy” (ἀνυπόκριτος). Matthew 7:5 thus inaugurates a motif coursing through apostolic teaching. Theological Significance: Heart over Appearance 1. Divine Omniscience—1 Sam 16:7, Hebrews 4:12-13: God discerns motives. 2. Necessity of Regeneration—John 3:3: inner transformation precedes righteous evaluation of others. 3. Sanctification Process—Phil 2:12-13: self-purification enables loving correction (cf. Galatians 6:1). Practical Application for Believers • Examine Self First—2 Cor 13:5. • Pursue Humility—1 Pet 5:5-6. • Restore Gently—Gal 6:1; removal of another’s speck is possible only after personal repentance. • Look to Christ—Heb 12:2: the sinless One who judges rightly (John 5:30). Historical and Manuscript Witness to Matthew 7:5 The verse appears in every extant manuscript tradition: • P64/67 (c. AD 175), the earliest Matthew fragments, read ὑποκριτά ! • Codices Vaticanus (B) and Sinaiticus (א), 4th century, confirm identical wording. • Over 2,200 Greek minuscules sustain the text, demonstrating stability. Early patristic citations—e.g., Didache 8.1; Justin Martyr, Apol. I.16—quote or allude to the passage, attesting to its original inclusion. Conclusion Matthew 7:5 crystallizes the Bible’s sweeping condemnation of hypocrisy: those who mask their own sin are unqualified to diagnose others. Consistent with both Old and New Testament witness, the verse summons every person to heartfelt repentance, authentic righteousness, and Christ-centered humility before offering moral critique. |
    |