What does Jesus mean by "Are you still so dull?" in Matthew 15:16? Passage “Jesus asked, ‘Are you still so dull? Do you not yet realize that whatever enters the mouth goes into the stomach and then is eliminated?’” (Matthew 15:16-17) Immediate Literary Setting: Matthew 15:1-20 Matthew records a confrontation between Jesus and Jerusalem Pharisees over ritual hand-washing. The leaders accuse the disciples of violating “the tradition of the elders” (v. 2). Jesus counters by exposing their hypocrisy, quoting Isaiah 29:13, and declaring that defilement is a matter of the heart, not ceremonial contact (vv. 3-11). Peter then asks for clarification of “the parable” (v. 15). Jesus’ reply begins with the rebuke in v. 16 and unfolds the principle: inward evil, not external food, defiles (vv. 17-20). Parallel Synoptic Witness: Mark 7:17-23 Mark’s account, written independently of Matthew yet affirming the same event, preserves the identical rebuke: “Are you so dull?” (Mark 7:18). The convergence of wording, setting, and lesson in two sources underscores historical reliability and indicates an authentic ipsissima vox (the very voice) of Jesus. Original Greek Term The word translated “dull” is ἀσύνετοι (asunetoi), plural of ἄσυνετος, “without understanding, unintelligent, foolish.” Septuagint usage aligns it with moral obtuseness (e.g., Proverbs 15:21 LXX). Jesus is not attacking intellect but spiritual perception; the disciples’ minds are functioning, yet their hearts lag in grasping kingdom realities. Function of the Rebuke 1. Rhetorical Shock: Ancient Jewish teachers often used sharp questions to jolt pupils into reflection (cf. Isaiah 1:5; Proverbs 1:22). 2. Discipleship Training: By correcting insiders rather than crowds, Jesus shapes leaders who will soon instruct others (Matthew 28:19-20). 3. Revelation of Heart Blindness: The immediate context contrasts external ritualists with disciples who should understand the heart emphasis yet momentarily share the same surface thinking. Theological Significance • Internal vs. External Holiness: Jesus reaffirms Mosaic emphasis on the heart (Deuteronomy 10:16; 30:6) and anticipates the New Covenant promise of internal transformation (Jeremiah 31:33; Ezekiel 36:26). • Doctrine of Illumination: Spiritual understanding ultimately requires divine enlightenment (1 Corinthians 2:14-16). The disciples’ dullness points forward to Pentecost, when the Spirit removes such blindness (Acts 2:4, 14-18). • Christological Authority: By overriding dietary traditions, Jesus implicitly claims authority over Torah interpretation, consistent with His divine identity (Matthew 5:21-48; 12:8). Old Testament Echoes and Foreshadowings Isaiah lamented those “who are wise in their own eyes” yet spiritually blind (Isaiah 5:21; 6:9-10). The disciples’ temporary dullness fulfills Isaiah’s observation but also highlights the prophetic promise that Messiah will open blind eyes (Isaiah 35:5). Applications for Believers Today 1. Examine Heart Orientation: Rituals may be good, yet heart motives must be central (Psalm 139:23-24). 2. Seek Spirit-Given Insight: Prayerfully ask for illumination (Ephesians 1:17-18). 3. Practice Discernment: Evaluate teachings and cultural traditions by Scripture, not vice versa (Acts 17:11; Colossians 2:8). 4. Display Humility: If apostles could be dull, modern disciples can too (Proverbs 3:5-6). Dependence on God prevents prideful blindness. Conclusion “Are you still so dull?” is a loving but firm summons to move beyond superficial religion into heart-level understanding granted by God. It spotlights the necessity of inner cleansing, fulfilled ultimately through Christ’s death and resurrection, applied by the Holy Spirit, and calls every generation to embrace transformed thinking that glorifies God. |
    |