How can we reconcile Psalm 139:22 with Jesus' command to love our enemies? Framing the Seeming Conflict - Psalm 139:22: “I hate them with perfect hatred; I count them as my enemies.” - Matthew 5:44: “But I tell you, love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you.” - At first glance, David’s “perfect hatred” and Jesus’ call to love appear to collide. Scripture never contradicts itself, so the key is to see how both texts speak to different yet complementary aspects of godly living. What David Means by “Perfect Hatred” - A covenant loyalty issue - David is speaking as Israel’s anointed king. Those who “hate” God (v. 21) threaten the covenant people; David’s words reflect zeal for God’s honor, not a petty grudge. - Moral alignment, not personal vengeance - “Perfect” (lit. “complete, total”) hatred is a settled, judicial stance against persistent, God-defying evil. - Compare Psalm 97:10: “Hate evil, you who love the LORD!” - Theocratic context - Under the old covenant, the king also served as chief magistrate of a theocratic nation. His hatred of evil was tied to public justice. What Jesus Commands in the Sermon on the Mount - Personal relationships - Jesus addresses disciples’ heart-responses, urging mercy even toward persecutors. - Reflecting the Father’s character - Matthew 5:45 points to the Father who “causes His sun to rise on the evil and the good.” - Overcoming evil with good - Romans 12:20–21 echoes the same ethic: “Do not be overcome by evil, but overcome evil with good.” Harmonizing the Two Passages 1. Different roles, same God - David the king: carries public responsibility to oppose God’s enemies. - A New-Covenant disciple: called to personal peacemaking while trusting God to judge. 2. Hating evil vs. hating persons - Scripture commands both: “Hate what is evil” (Romans 12:9) and “Love your enemies.” - A believer may abhor evil systems or deeds yet still seek the salvation of those trapped in them. 3. Progressive revelation, consistent ethic - The cross reveals God’s ultimate answer to evil—sacrificial love that still upholds justice (Romans 3:25-26). 4. Leaving vengeance to God - David’s words anticipate God’s final judgment; Jesus teaches us to defer judgment, trusting, “Vengeance is Mine, I will repay” (Romans 12:19). Living It Out Today - Identify and renounce genuine evil without indulging personal bitterness. - Pray for the repentance of enemies, mirroring Christ’s “Father, forgive them” (Luke 23:34). - Maintain a clear moral spine: call sin what it is, protect the vulnerable, yet refuse to retaliate in kind. - Rest in God’s ultimate justice; He alone perfectly balances wrath and mercy. In David’s “perfect hatred” we see righteous allegiance to God’s holiness; in Jesus’ command we see the fullest expression of God’s love. Embracing both guards us from softening sin on one hand or succumbing to spite on the other, leading us into mature, Christ-like faithfulness. |
    |