How does Romans 11:5 relate to the concept of predestination? Text of Romans 11:5 “So too, at the present time there is a remnant chosen by grace.” Immediate Literary Context Paul has traced God’s saving purpose from Abraham (Romans 4) through the justified-by-faith community (Romans 5–8) and then turned to Israel’s unbelief (Romans 9–11). In chapter 11 he corrects any notion that God has rejected His covenant people. Verse 5 follows Paul’s citation of 1 Kings 19:18 (v. 4), showing that in Elijah’s day—and now—God preserves a believing minority. This “remnant” theme is the hinge between Israel’s past election and its future restoration (vv. 25-32). Old Testament Background of the Remnant 1. Isaiah 1:9; 10:20-22—Israel survives judgment only because “a remnant will return.” 2. Micah 2:12; Zephaniah 3:12-13—God gathers a humble remnant who trust in His name. 3. 1 Kings 19:18—Yahweh reserves 7,000 who do not bow to Baal. In each case the remnant exists because of divine initiative, not human merit—foreshadowing the grace language of Romans 11:5. Systematic Theological Link to Predestination 1. Romans 8:29-30—“Those He foreknew He also predestined…called…justified…glorified.” 2. Romans 9:11-13—Jacob and Esau illustrate that election precedes works. 3. Ephesians 1:4-5—God “chose us…having predestined us.” Romans 11:5 fits seamlessly: the present believing Jews are included because God predestined a grace remnant; thus predestination is the fountainhead of their existence. Individual and Corporate Dimensions Paul speaks corporately of Israel (nation) yet narrows to individuals (“there is a remnant”). Predestination encompasses: • Corporate—God foreordains a people (Israel, the Church). • Individual—each member of the remnant personally experiences grace-driven faith (v. 23, “if they do not persist in unbelief, they will be grafted in”). Grace and Human Responsibility Verse 6 (immediately following) draws an antithesis: “And if it is by grace, it is no longer by works.” Election cannot depend on foreseen human merit yet does not nullify human response (11:20, “you stand by faith”). Predestination secures the possibility and certainty of faith; it never suppresses it. Canonical Harmony • Deuteronomy 7:7-8—Israel was loved “because the LORD loved you,” a self-referential cause parallel to grace election. • John 6:37-40—All whom the Father gives will come; none are lost. • Acts 13:48—“All who were appointed for eternal life believed.” These passages echo Romans 11:5: appointment precedes belief, ensuring a remnant’s faith. Early Church Witness • Irenaeus (Against Heresies 3.16.3) cites Romans 11 to argue that God saves “those whom He foreknew.” • Augustine (On the Predestination of the Saints 4) appeals to Romans 11:5-6 for unconditional election by grace. The patristic consensus viewed the remnant as a proof of predestination, not mere foreknowledge of future decisions. Philosophical and Behavioral Observations Research on locus of control and gratitude correlates a belief in unmerited favor with increased humility and altruism. Predestination, rightly understood, fosters assurance (Romans 8:38-39) and evangelistic zeal (Romans 11:13-14), rather than fatalism. Common Objections Answered 1. Objection: Predestination violates free will. Response: Scripture presents compatibilism; divine sovereignty determines outcomes while humans act voluntarily (Acts 2:23). 2. Objection: Election is corporate only. Response: Paul’s olive-tree analogy (vv. 17-24) involves individual branches, not merely a corporate trunk. 3. Objection: Election is based on foreseen faith. Response: Romans 9:16, “It does not, therefore, depend on man’s desire or effort, but on God’s mercy” (cf. 11:6). Pastoral Implications Believers of Jewish and Gentile origin can rest in the security of God’s eternal purpose. The existence of a remnant ensures that God’s promises have not failed, guaranteeing future fulfillment and motivating present proclamation. Conclusion Romans 11:5 teaches that the present remnant of believing Israelites exists solely because of God’s gracious predestination. The verse integrates Old Testament remnant theology, Pauline soteriology, and the broader biblical doctrine of election, demonstrating that salvation from first to last is “of the LORD” (Jonah 2:9) and accomplished for His glory (Romans 11:36). |
    |