What does 1 Samuel 28:9 reveal about Saul's spiritual state? Text: 1 Samuel 28:9 “But the woman said to him, ‘Surely you know what Saul has done. He has cut off the mediums and spiritists from the land. Why then are you setting a trap for my life to cause my death?’ ” Immediate Literary Setting The verse sits inside the narrative of Saul’s secret nighttime visit to the medium of En-dor after God had refused to answer him “by dreams or Urim or prophets” (28:6). The woman’s protest reminds the reader that the king himself had earlier enforced the Mosaic ban on occult practice (cf. Leviticus 19:31; Deuteronomy 18:10-12). Her words spotlight Saul’s turn from obedience to contradiction, a pivot that exposes the state of his soul. Covenantal and Legal Background 1. Divine Prohibition: Israel’s covenant law pronounced necromancy a capital offense (Leviticus 20:6, 27). 2. Royal Enforcement: Saul had once upheld that law, a duty of kingship (Deuteronomy 17:18-20). Verse 9 confirms that enforcement had been public, systematic, and well known. 3. Disobedient Reversal: By seeking what he had outlawed, Saul places himself under the very judgment he once invoked on others. Theological Diagnosis of Saul’s Spiritual State 1. Willful Knowledge Rejection – He knows the law and his own edict; the woman’s words assume his full awareness. 2. Hypocrisy and Double-Mindedness (James 1:8) – Outwardly righteous in earlier reforms, inwardly rebellious when fear mounts. 3. Fear-Driven Desperation – 1 Samuel 28:5 records that Saul’s “heart trembled greatly.” Fear replaces faith, producing disobedience (Romans 14:23). 4. Severed Fellowship with God – 1 Samuel 16:14: “The Spirit of the LORD departed from Saul.” 28:6 confirms divine silence. His resort to forbidden channels is symptomatic of estrangement. 5. Encroaching Apostasy – By seeking guidance from the realm of the dead, he declares functional allegiance to powers opposed to Yahweh (1 Chron 10:13-14). Psychological and Behavioral Insights Modern behavioral science recognizes cognitive dissonance—the tension created when actions violate held beliefs. Saul mitigates dissonance not by repentance but by concealment (disguising himself, 28:8). Persistent dissonance can culminate in moral collapse, matching Saul’s spiral toward self-destruction (31:4). Historical and Cultural Corroboration Excavations at Tel Jezreel and the Jezreel Valley have produced Philistine pottery layers consistent with the late Iron I chronology of Saul’s reign, corroborating the geopolitical setting that drove his panic over the Philistine threat (28:4). Cuneiform texts from Emar and Ugarit list royal bans on necromancers, paralleling Saul’s earlier purge and validating the cultural milieu in which mediums were simultaneously consulted and outlawed. Canonical Cross-References • Saul’s earlier obedience: 1 Samuel 15:24–26 exposes his pattern of selective submission. • Divine silence as covenant judgment: Proverbs 1:28; Isaiah 59:2. • Contrast with David’s response to crisis: 1 Samuel 30:8—David “inquired of the LORD.” • NT parallel: Acts 8:9-24 contrasts false spiritual power (Simon Magus) with genuine repentance. Pastoral and Evangelistic Application • Inquiry: “If you, like Saul, find heaven silent, will you humble yourself or run to counterfeit spiritualities?” • Invitation: Christ, unlike Saul, obeyed perfectly and rose victoriously; He mediates access to God (Hebrews 4:14-16). • Exhortation: Abandon occult curiosity; seek the living God who speaks through Scripture and the resurrected Christ. Conclusion 1 Samuel 28:9 exposes Saul’s spiritual degeneration: informed yet defiant, outwardly reformed yet inwardly rebellious, fearful yet unrepentant. The verse crystallizes the tragedy of a leader who, having once defended God’s law, surrenders to the very sin he had condemned. The episode stands as permanent caution: knowledge without obedience leads to spiritual ruin, but humble submission to God’s revealed word leads to life. |
    |