What does Num 11:5 show about Israel's view?
How does Numbers 11:5 reveal the Israelites' attitude towards God's provision?

Setting the Scene

The people have been traveling for roughly a year since leaving Egypt (Exodus 12–Numbers 10). Every morning the LORD provides manna—bread from heaven (Exodus 16:4-15). Yet the crowd begins to complain. Numbers 11:4 says, “the rabble that was among them had greedy cravings.” Their words in verse 5 pull back the curtain on the heart of the nation.


Key Verse

“We remember the fish we ate freely in Egypt, along with the cucumbers, melons, leeks, onions, and garlic.” (Numbers 11:5)


What Their Words Reveal

• Selective memory

 – They recall Egypt’s menu “freely,” ignoring the bitter slavery (Exodus 1:13-14).

• Discontent with God’s provision

 – Manna, a daily miracle, fails to satisfy their cravings (Numbers 11:6).

• Craving for variety over sufficiency

 – The list of six foods contrasts one simple food from God, hinting that God’s gift looks bland to fleshly appetites.

• Earth-bound appetite

 – Focus on what gratifies the palate instead of God’s deliverance and promises (Deuteronomy 8:3).

• Ingratitude

 – Psalm 78:18-20 notes they “tested God in their hearts.” They treat the Provider as inadequate.

• Unbelief

 – By exalting Egypt’s produce, they doubt God will sustain them through the wilderness to Canaan (Hebrews 3:12-19).


Comparing Manna and Egypt’s Menu

Food Source

• Egypt: abundance comes with chains.

• Manna: heaven-sent, comes with freedom.

Preparation

• Egypt: earned by labor under taskmasters.

• Manna: gathered with ease, requiring trust (Exodus 16:16-18).

Symbolism

• Egypt: nourishes nostalgia for bondage.

• Manna: prefigures Christ, “the true bread from heaven” (John 6:31-35).


Consequences of Complaining

• Fire of the LORD at Taberah (Numbers 11:1-3).

• Plague after quail lust (Numbers 11:31-34).

Psalm 106:13-15—He “granted their request, but sent leanness into their souls.”

• Paul warns believers by this example (1 Corinthians 10:6-10).


Lessons for Today

• Gratitude safeguards the heart; complaining magnifies imagined losses.

• Longing for past comforts can blind believers to present miracles.

• God’s provision is perfect for His purpose, even when it lacks the variety flesh desires.

• True freedom is better than bondage with luxuries.

Numbers 11:5 thus unmasks a heart that treasures former slavery’s flavors more than the living God’s daily bread—a timeless caution against despising divine provision.

What is the meaning of Numbers 11:5?
Top of Page
Top of Page