What does Numbers 20:11 mean?
What is the meaning of Numbers 20:11?

Then Moses raised his hand

• Moses responds to the people’s desperate cries for water (Numbers 20:2-5).

• His uplifted hand signals authority granted by God, similar to Exodus 17:11 when he raised his hands during battle.

• At this moment Moses is expected to speak to the rock (Numbers 20:8), yet his gesture hints he is moving toward a different course.

Psalm 106:32-33 later notes that the people’s provocation “caused trouble for Moses,” underscoring the emotional pressure behind the lifted hand.


and struck the rock twice with his staff

• God had earlier instructed Moses to strike a rock once at Horeb (Exodus 17:6). Here, striking twice exposes doubt and frustration, departing from the simple act of speaking.

Deuteronomy 32:51 confirms that this disobedience—failing to uphold God’s holiness before Israel—barred Moses from entering Canaan.

• The staff, once a symbol of obedience (Exodus 4:20), now illustrates that even trusted leaders can falter.

1 Corinthians 10:4 identifies the wilderness rock as a type pointing to Christ; striking it twice distorts that typology, because the Messiah would be “struck” only once for sin (Hebrews 10:10).


so that a great amount of water gushed out

• Despite Moses’ error, God graciously provides. His faithfulness to His covenant people outshines human failure (Psalm 78:15-16; Isaiah 48:21).

• The abundance—“a great amount”—reminds us of God’s superabundant provision, echoed when Jesus multiplies loaves and fish (Matthew 14:20).

Psalm 105:41 celebrates this miracle: “He opened a rock, and water gushed out; it flowed like a river in the desert.”


and the congregation and their livestock were able to drink

• God cares for the whole community—men, women, children, and even animals (Jonah 4:11).

• The scene mirrors Psalm 23:1-2: “The LORD is my shepherd… He leads me beside quiet waters,” confirming His shepherd heart in barren places.

• Provision for livestock underscores future sustainability; the people can now continue toward the Promised Land (Numbers 32:1).

• This mercy, given immediately after grumbling, showcases Romans 2:4: God’s kindness is meant to lead to repentance.


summary

Numbers 20:11 records a moment where God’s faithfulness meets human failure. Moses lifts his hand, but in frustration strikes the rock twice instead of speaking. Yet water still pours out abundantly, sustaining Israel and their animals. The episode reminds us that God keeps His promises even when His servants stumble, while also teaching that leaders must honor His holiness by obeying precisely.

What does Numbers 20:10 reveal about God's expectations for obedience?
Top of Page
Top of Page