Why did God put Er to death in Genesis 38:7? Canonical Text “But Er, Judah’s firstborn, was wicked in the sight of the LORD; so the LORD put him to death.” (Genesis 38:7) Immediate Literary Context Genesis 38 interrupts the Joseph narrative to trace Judah’s line. Judah leaves his covenant family, marries a Canaanite (38:2), and raises three sons—Er, Onan, Shelah. The sins of Er and Onan are judged before the narrative returns to Joseph in Genesis 39. Moses deliberately places the episode here to explain how Perez (ancestor of David and Christ, Ruth 4:18–22; Matthew 1:3) enters Judah’s genealogy. Meaning of “Wicked” (Hebrew רַע, raʿ) The term denotes active evil, moral corruption, or culpable wrong‐doing “in the sight of the LORD.” It is used for the antediluvians (Genesis 6:5), Sodom (Genesis 13:13), and Israel under the judges (Judges 2:11). It is qualitative, not merely a single lapse. Er’s pattern of life stood in conscious rebellion against Yahweh. Probable Forms of Er’s Sin Scripture is concise, yet surrounding clues narrow the options: 1. Canaanite Assimilation – Judah’s marriage to a Canaanite woman (38:2) signals syncretism. Idolatry consistently incurs capital sanction (Exodus 22:20; Deuteronomy 17:2–5). 2. Sexual Immorality – The very next verse judges Onan for sexual sin (38:9–10). Rabbinic tradition (b. Yebamoth 34b) claims Er practiced coitus interruptus to avoid conception with Tamar, thus despising the creation mandate (Genesis 1:28) and the levirate principle later codified (Deuteronomy 25:5–10). While extra‐biblical, the juxtaposition lends historical plausibility. 3. Contempt for Covenant Lineage – As firstborn, Er held the legal right of primogeniture (later formalized, Deuteronomy 21:15–17) and the spiritual privilege of channeling the Abrahamic blessing. Active refusal to fulfill that role places him with Esau who “despised his birthright” (Genesis 25:34). Theological Purpose of Immediate Judgment 1. Preserving the Messianic Line – By removing Er (and Onan), God positions Tamar to bear Perez, through whom the promised Seed advances. Divine sovereignty works through judgment as well as mercy (cf. Isaiah 45:7). 2. Safeguarding Covenant Holiness – Prior to Sinai God already enforces holy boundaries (e.g., flood, Sodom, Nadab & Abihu, Leviticus 10:1–2). Early, decisive interventions teach Israel—and ultimately the nations—that Yahweh’s moral law is inherent to His nature (Leviticus 11:44). 3. Foreshadowing Corporate Warnings – Later Israel will hear, “I will remove the wicked from among you” (Numbers 16; Deuteronomy 13). Er’s fate is a preview of the covenant blessings and curses (Leviticus 26; Deuteronomy 28). Comparative Biblical Judgments • Antediluvians – global flood for widespread “wickedness” (Genesis 6:5–7). • Sodom & Gomorrah – regional destruction for sexual perversion and injustice (Genesis 19). • Nadab & Abihu – death for unauthorized worship (Leviticus 10:2). • Ananias & Sapphira – instantaneous death in the New Testament church (Acts 5:1–11). These parallels affirm continuity: Yahweh judges personal and communal sin consistently across eras. God’s Justice and Mercy Balanced Psalm 89:14: “Righteousness and justice are the foundation of Your throne…” God’s holiness necessitates judgment; His mercy provides atonement (Leviticus 17:11). The same narrative that removes Er sets the stage for Perez, ancestor to “Jesus the Messiah, the Son of David” (Matthew 1:1). Judgment becomes an instrument of redemptive mercy for the world. Philosophical and Behavioral Implications Human autonomy divorced from divine authority produces death (Romans 6:23). Er’s life offers a behavioral case study: entrenched wickedness, even in a covenant family, culminates in self‐destruction under divine justice. Modern behavioral science confirms that persistent antisocial conduct correlates with negative life outcomes; Scripture locates the ultimate cause in sinful rebellion (Jeremiah 17:9). Practical Applications 1. Sobriety about Sin – God sees beyond outward credentials (firstborn status) to inward disposition. 2. Urgency of Repentance – “Today, if you hear His voice, do not harden your hearts” (Hebrews 3:15). 3. Hope in Christ – The narrative drives toward Perez, Boaz, David, and finally Christ, whose resurrection conquers the death that claimed Er (1 Corinthians 15:22). Answer Summarized God put Er to death because his persistent, covenant‐despising wickedness threatened the holiness of the chosen line and the unfolding plan of redemption. The action illustrates Yahweh’s unwavering justice, preserves the Messianic lineage, and warns every generation that “the eyes of the LORD are in every place, observing the evil and the good” (Proverbs 15:3). |
    |