Why did God allow the Israelites to feel sorry for Benjamin in Judges 21:15? Text of the Passage (Judges 21:15) “The people grieved for Benjamin, because the LORD had made a gap among the tribes of Israel.” Historical Setting: Civil War After Gibeah Israel’s sorrow erupts after a self-inflicted catastrophe. In response to the atrocity at Gibeah (Judges 19), the other eleven tribes swore an oath to annihilate the offenders (Judges 20:1-11) and then almost wiped out the entire tribe of Benjamin—leaving only 600 men alive (Judges 20:47). Judges 21 opens with Israel realizing the unintended consequences of its zeal: a covenant people now missing an entire tribe. Divine Justice Meets Human Responsibility 1. Benjamin’s near-extinction is portrayed as righteous judgment on unrepentant wickedness (Judges 20:12-13). 2. Yet God never sanctioned permanent tribal erasure. The covenant with Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob presupposed twelve tribes (Genesis 35:22-26). 3. Scripture therefore stresses that “the LORD had made a gap” (Judges 21:15). God’s sovereignty over events does not absolve Israel of culpability; it highlights the delicate tension between divine judgment and human agency (cf. Acts 2:23). Covenantal Preservation of Twelve Tribes Jacob’s prophetic blessing had already assigned Benjamin a perpetual role: “Benjamin is a ravenous wolf; in the morning he devours the prey, and in the evening he divides the plunder” (Genesis 49:27). Covenant structure demands Benjamin’s survival so that: • Saul, the first king, may arise from Benjamin (1 Samuel 9). • Esther’s cousin Mordecai, a Benjaminite, may preserve the exiles (Esther 2:5). • The apostle Paul, “of the tribe of Benjamin” (Philippians 3:5), may become the missionary to the Gentiles. Had Benjamin vanished, these later redemptive milestones could not occur. Thus God stirred compassion to align Israel’s emotions with His unfolding plan. Emotional Awakening as Divine Instrument Scripture consistently records God eliciting human compassion to accomplish His purposes (Exodus 2:6; Nehemiah 1:4). The grief in Judges 21:15 serves at least four ends: 1. Remorse: Israel recognizes the disproportion between crime and punishment. 2. Repentance: The nation seeks atonement by sacrificial worship at Bethel (Judges 21:4). 3. Restoration: Compassion motivates creative—though deeply flawed—solutions to supply wives for the 600 survivors (Judges 21:16-23). 4. Reminder: Emotional pain underscores the consequences of rash vows (cf. Ecclesiastes 5:2). The Role of Free Will and Oaths Israel’s self-imposed oath (“None of us shall give his daughter to Benjamin,” Judges 21:1) boxed them into moral paradox. God permitted the gravity of their oath to play out so they would grasp the seriousness of invoking His name lightly (Leviticus 19:12). Their sorrow demonstrates how divine sovereignty can allow self-inflicted wounds to become catalytic lessons (Deuteronomy 32:29). Archaeological and Textual Reliability • Tell el-Fûl (commonly equated with Gibeah) has burn layers consistent with late Bronze/early Iron I destruction, matching Judges 20. • The Mesad Hashavyahu ostracon (7th century BC) and Lachish letters show the Hebrew legal language of covenant and oath reflected in Judges 21. • The earliest extant Hebrew manuscripts (e.g., Dead Sea Scroll fragment 4QJudg) and all major Greek codices preserve Judges 21:15 verbatim, underscoring textual stability. Foreshadowing of Christ’s Compassion The narrative anticipates the gospel pattern: judgment deserved, compassion extended, remnant preserved. Christ embodies this fully—“For God has consigned all men to disobedience so that He may have mercy on them all” (Romans 11:32). Just as Israel’s sorrow preserved a remnant, Christ’s sorrow over Jerusalem (Luke 19:41) inaugurates redemption. Practical Implications for Believers 1. Guard the tongue; rash vows can scar generations. 2. Balance righteous indignation with measured mercy. 3. Trust that God can sovereignly steer even our failures toward His covenant purposes (Romans 8:28). 4. Maintain unity in the body of Christ, valuing every “tribe” and gifting. Answer in Brief God allowed Israel to feel deep sorrow for Benjamin to: • reveal the gravity of sin and hasty vengeance, • preserve the covenantal integrity of the twelve tribes, • awaken national repentance and compassion, • foreshadow His ultimate plan of justice tempered by mercy in Christ. |
    |