Why did King Josiah ignore Pharaoh Neco's message from God in 2 Chronicles 35:21? Historical Setting King Josiah reigned c. 640–609 BC (Ussher: 3374–3414 AM). After purging Judah of idolatry and renewing the covenant (2 Chron 34; 35:1-19), he encountered Pharaoh Neco II of Egypt, who was marching north to aid Assyria against the rising Babylonians at Carchemish (Babylonian Chronicle, ABC 5; Neco’s Karnak inscriptions). The confrontation took place in 609 BC on the plain of Megiddo (2 Kings 23:29; 2 Chron 35:20-24). The Claim: “Words from the Mouth of God” 2 Chron 35:21-22—“But Neco sent messengers to him, saying, ‘… God has told me to hurry… For your sake, refrain from meddling with God, who is with me, lest He destroy you.’ …Josiah…did not heed Neco’s words from the mouth of God.” The Chronicler, writing under divine inspiration, explicitly identifies Neco’s warning as a genuine divine message. Therefore the narrative places Josiah, not Neco, in the position of error. Biblical Precedents of God Speaking through Non-Israelites • Balaam, a pagan seer (Numbers 22–24) • Cyrus of Persia, called God’s “shepherd” and “anointed” (Isaiah 44:28; 45:1) • Nebuchadnezzar’s dream interpreted as God-sent (Daniel 2; 4) These precedents show that God, while chiefly revealing Himself through Israel, occasionally speaks through foreign rulers to accomplish His purposes (cf. Romans 9:17). Analyzing Josiah’s Refusal 1. Zeal for Covenant Loyalty Josiah had sworn to eradicate idolatry and foreign influence (2 Kings 23:4-20). Egypt’s long history as Israel’s oppressor (Exodus 20:2) could have made him instinctively distrustful of any “divine” claim from that quarter. 2. Political-Military Calculus Aligning with Babylon against Egypt-Assyria appeared advantageous for Judah’s security. Jeremiah, pro-Babylonian at the time (Jeremiah 25:8-11), may have reinforced the perception that Egypt’s advance threatened prophetic expectations. 3. Misreading Previous Prophetic Assurance Huldah’s promise—“you will be gathered to your grave in peace” (2 Kings 22:20)—might have been interpreted by Josiah as a blanket shield, leading him to underestimate danger. Chronicles clarifies that the “peace” referred to national, not personal, calamity. 4. Spiritual Overconfidence After Reform Successes Triumphs in religious reform and Passover celebration (2 Chron 35:1-19) may have fostered an assumption that God would automatically endorse any subsequent initiative (Proverbs 16:18). 5. Failure to Apply the Scriptural Test Deut 18:21-22 instructs testing a prophetic word’s authenticity. Josiah did not seek confirmation from contemporary prophets (e.g., Jeremiah, Zephaniah) as he had earlier consulted Huldah (2 Kings 22:14-15). His deliberate disguise (2 Chron 35:22) echoes Ahab’s fatal stratagem (2 Chron 18:29), a narrative parallel warning against ignoring divine counsel. Providential Purposes in Josiah’s Death God’s sovereignty weaves human decisions into His redemptive timeline: • Josiah’s early death spared him the trauma of witnessing Jerusalem’s destruction (cf. Isaiah 57:1-2). • It removed Judah’s last godly king, hastening the Babylonian exile predicted by the prophets, thereby vindicating covenant sanctions (Leviticus 26; Deuteronomy 28). • It fulfilled 1 Kings 13:2—Josiah’s name was prophesied three centuries earlier; his life and death bookend a specific prophetic arc demonstrating Scripture’s cohesiveness. Archaeological and Historical Corroboration – The Babylonian Chronicle (BM 21946) records Neco’s 609 BC campaign and the subsequent Babylonian victory at Carchemish (605 BC). – Herodotus (Hist. 2.159–160) references Neco II’s military projects and engagement at the Euphrates. – Excavations at Megiddo (Chicago Oriental Institute) confirm constant Late Iron Age fortifications, consistent with a strategic battlefield. These external sources align with the Chronicles/Kings timeline, reinforcing the historical credibility of the account. Theological and Practical Lessons • Divine authority is absolute, regardless of the messenger’s nationality (Acts 10:34-35). • Spiritual discernment requires humility and consultation with God’s established revelation and prophetic voices (Proverbs 11:14). • Past obedience does not exempt one from present vigilance (1 Corinthians 10:12). • God’s larger redemptive plan may incorporate the seemingly tragic (Romans 8:28). Conclusion Josiah ignored Pharaoh Neco’s God-given warning because zeal, political judgment, prophetic misinterpretation, and overconfidence combined to eclipse discernment. Scripture presents his death not as divine inconsistency but as a sober reminder that God’s word—whether delivered through prophet, priest, king, or foreign ruler—demands humble attention. |
    |