Why does Ecclesiastes 2:26 suggest God gives tasks to sinners? Full Text “For to the man who is pleasing in His sight, He gives wisdom, knowledge, and joy; but to the sinner He gives the task of gathering and accumulating to give it to the one who is pleasing in God’s sight. This too is futile and a pursuit of the wind.” — Ecclesiastes 2:26 Immediate Literary Setting Ecclesiastes 2 concludes a personal experiment with pleasure, labor, and intellectual achievement “under the sun.” Verse 26 functions as the Author’s inspired verdict: apart from God, even success in acquisition collapses into futility. The verse contrasts two classes—“the man who is pleasing” (hā’āḏām ṭôḇ lip̱nâw) and “the sinner” (le·ḥōṭē’). God’s active distribution of both blessings and burdens is central to the claim. Theological Principle: Divine Allocation of Roles Scripture consistently teaches that God apportions both blessings and burdens (Job 1:21; Isaiah 45:7). The righteous receive inner gifts—wisdom, knowledge, joy—while the unrighteous are ordained external tasks whose ultimate yield passes to God’s people. This is not capricious; it is an expression of holy justice (Proverbs 13:22; 28:8; Job 27:16-17). Common Grace versus Special Favor All people experience “common grace” (Matthew 5:45). Yet special favor—salvific and covenantal—is reserved for those “pleasing in His sight,” i.e., justified by faith (Genesis 15:6; Hebrews 11:6). Ecclesiastes 2:26 illustrates both categories simultaneously: God sustains sinners with life and ability to work, but withholds the ultimate satisfaction that only relationship with Him supplies. Divine Redistribution as Judgment and Blessing Biblical history repeatedly records unbelievers amassing resources that later support God’s redemptive agenda: • Exodus 12:35-36—Egyptian wealth transferred to Israel. • 1 Chronicles 29:2-16—spoils from pagan nations furnish materials for the temple. • Ezra 1:1-7—Persian treasury finances post-exilic worship. Archaeological corroborations include jewelry caches in the Sinai region dated to the Late Bronze Age and the Cyrus Cylinder (British Museum, ca. 539 B.C.) validating Persian royal decrees favoring Judah. Exposure of Futility to Prompt Repentance Romans 2:4 reminds that God’s kindness leads to repentance; conversely, toil without joy exposes emptiness so that sinners might seek grace. Behavioral studies in positive psychology confirm that material acquisition without transcendent purpose fails to secure long-term well-being, echoing the preacher’s cry of “vanity.” Integrative Canonical Harmony • Psalm 73 documents Asaph’s near-envy of the wicked’s prosperity until he discerns their end. • Luke 12:16-21 (Parable of the Rich Fool) embodies Ecclesiastes 2:26 in narrative form. • James 5:1-6 warns wealthy oppressors of coming judgment, reinforcing the redistribution motif. Christological Fulfillment Christ personifies the “pleasing man” (Matthew 3:17). At Calvary the “wealth” of sin—its wages of death—was laid on Him (2 Corinthians 5:21), then redistributed to believers as righteousness, wisdom, and joy (1 Corinthians 1:30). The cross thus magnifies the principle hinted in Ecclesiastes: God reverses fortunes to glorify Himself and bless His people. Practical Implications for Believers 1. Contentment: recognize wisdom, knowledge, and joy as direct gifts from God, not self-generated (1 Timothy 6:6-8). 2. Stewardship: hold material goods loosely; they were never ultimate ends (Matthew 6:19-21). 3. Evangelism: testify to those who toil without peace that true satisfaction resides in reconciliation with God through Christ (John 4:13-14). Answer in Summary God “gives tasks to sinners” to manifest His sovereignty, to supply His covenant people, to expose the emptiness of life apart from Him, and ultimately to direct all glory back to Himself. Sinners’ ceaseless accumulation, while real labor, is providentially harnessed into the grand redemptive economy that culminates in the wisdom, knowledge, and joy granted to those who are in Christ. |
    |